Photo editing dilemma

I spend pretty much the entire day pulling images and editing them for the Web. I do this in both Windows and Linux, and since I neither have nor want Photoshop, I've been using both free and free, open-source programs to get the job done.

Free ... free and open-source -- what's the difference?

Let me throw in two more terms: Shareware and crapware.

Let's knock 'em down:

Crapware: "Free" software included on a new PCs hard drive that only functions for a limited period of time, after which the computer owner must purchase it or discontinue its use. Source code not included or available.

Shareware: Software that is initially free to download and install, sometimes in a full version, other times in a truncated form, that can be used for either a certain period of time or forever, but which can be purchased -- or must be purchased to continue using after a period of time. Source code not included or available.

Freeware: Software that can be freely downloaded and used, but not necessarily freely distributed. Source code not included or available.

Free, open-source software: This is the GPL (GNU General Public License) model that governs most Linux system software and the applications that go with it. Software is freely available, source code is also freely available and can be modified and re-released provided source code for the subsequent revision is also included. Software can be repackaged and sold ... but the source code must continue to be made available free of charge.

At least that is my understanding of the various levels of "free" and not-so-free software.

Over the past decade or so, the model has shifted from mostly shareware to mostly FOSS (free, open-source software). That's a good -- and probably a great -- thing. Keeping the code open makes it easier to find and fix problems and to create new applications from a code base.

Anyway ... back to my image-editing problem. I love the GIMP, the free, open-source photo-editing program that runs on Windows, Mac and Linux/BSD. I've barely used Photoshop in all my years of computing, so I don't miss it.

But one of my "new" tasks at work is preparing photos with embedded IPTC info -- caption and credit information that is part of the JPEG file. I can't find a FOSS photo editing program that both lets me do what I need to do in terms of image sizing and cropping as well as preserving and modifying the IPTC infomation.

The GIMP obliterates the IPTC info. I've since tried Krita (from the KDE software family) and my favorite light image-editor, MtPaint, and neither allows access to the IPTC info.

But one of the freeware editors I use on my Windows box, IrfanView, does allow access to IPTC. If you get the main program and all its plugins, you have a lot of power at your fingertips. It's not as easy -- for me, at least -- as the GIMP, but it is extremely quick to load. And it appears to do the job.

IrfanView is freeware, not FOSS, which troubles me a bit. But its developer, Irfan Skiljan of Austria, is a fantastic programmer, and I can't begrudge him licensing the application the way he sees fit.

Oh, and I wish IrfanView was available for Linux and the Mac. One can dream.

Update: I guess you can call Irfanview a kind of shareware. It does cost:

If you intend to use IrfanView at your place of business or for commercial purposes, please register and purchase it. I want to continue working on this program, therefore, your registration will be an incentive for me to add new functions and increase the program's quality.

Any suggestions, feedback and comments are welcome and won't be ignored.

If you are a commercial user and you like this program (or are a home user who wants to support/donate further development), please register/donate by sending US$ 12.00 or EUR 10,- (this is the price for one (single) licence) to the address below.

Please send cash only. (I cannot accept high check cashing fees at the bank)

Address:

Irfan Skiljan

Postfach 48

2700 Wiener Neustadt

Austria, Europe

Commercial users: please contact me by E-Mail for prices and discounts. Note: If you want, you can buy the licenses using PayPal or credit card.

Even though I prefer "free," $12 U.S. is an excellent deal. If I use IrfanView for a week and it does what I want, I'll pay up. Especially given the current dollar-euro exchange rate, it's a deal for U.S. users vis a vis Europeans.