Question: Can we trust Google with our data?

| | Comments (1) |

It's not just Gmail, but Google Docs and Spreadsheets, and even more data in Google's cloud. Can individuals and even corporations trust Google with their information?

I know they have the whole "don't be evil" thing going on, but isn't "evil" in the eye of the beholder.

On the other hand, is Google technically competent enough to keep the data from being damaged or destroyed? And on the other, other hand, maybe Google (or Amazon, IBM or what have you) is way, way better-equipped to be in charge of your data than you are.

The big question: Will Google roll over on you when the goverment comes a-callin'. I don't know what Google's record is on this, and the whole thing is a legal quagmire in the making.

From a purely technical standpoint, it might be a good idea to keep local backups, even if all your data is in Google, Amazon/Red Hat, IBM or whoever's cloud.

But considering how poor most of us (myself included) are at making and keeping backups, cloud computing and data storage is probably a pretty good idea.

But I throw it to you: Do you trust Google?

1 Comments

dbr said:

Yes. They aren't getting any information I don't type into their website.

What are they going to do with this data? When "the goverment comes a-callin'" they can just as easily get the same data from your local machine if you do something to merit them doing so.

I really don't see what Google, or any big company is going to do with the data. The worst I can think of is selling all the email addresses to spammers, but a big company doing that without permission of their users would get sued instantly and such.

Besides, you don't have to sign up for a Google account. There are plenty of services to remove that cookie Google Search sets (Although I though the hysteria about cookies had died down), and I don't consider it all that much of a privacy problem.

The problem I do have with all this is speed, and reliability. A web-browser based word-processor is never going to be as responsive as a native desktop application, ever. A harddrive can write a file with very low latency, at very high speeds. Saving a document in a web-browser is going to take at least a few seconds, and is subject to session timeouts and other fun problems.

But my biggest problem is that Javascript and HTML really isn't designed to make spreadsheet applications.
They are inefficient (I imported a ~50 line CSV file into Google Spreadsheet, and tried to make a graph of it. About 30 seconds of 100% CPU usage it eventually produced a graph. Doing the same thing in a native application would have taken less than a second), and glitchy (Dragging selections sometimes reverts back to the "browser way", rather than the javascript-enhanced select-rows-or-columns stuff - Edit>Select All sometimes selects all columns, or all HTML)

They *are* convenient for quick documents, and if you want to work in two different places with an internet connection.

Personally I'd rather have the documents as files on a drive, where I can use any text editor on any machine (regardless of internet connection)

It's nothing to do with not-trusting-Google, but rather not trusting my internet connection. Yeh, it'll be up most of the time, but if the files are stored locally, it's a non-issue.

I did use Writely (which Google aquired) once or twice for it's collaborative editing thing, although we eventually ended up using Gobby as it showed other peoples edits in real time.

Leave a comment

Tech Talk column

Steven Rosenberg's weekly Tech Talk column, which appears Saturdays in the Los Angeles Daily News, is now available on the Daily News Technology page.

About this blog

New ways to sign in to comment: I just added the ability for prospective commenters on this blog to sign in using their AOL, Yahoo! and Wordpress.com accounts (for the past 200 posts anyway ... more than that will take an extensive, middle-of-the-night rebuild). That's in addition to the other sign-in choices, which include starting a Movable Type account on this blog, Typekey, OpenID, Live Journal and Vox. If you have trouble getting your Movable Type account verified, or any of the other sign-in options are not working properly, please e-mail me. With these added ways of signing in, there's more reason than ever for you to make a comment (or several!).




Steven Rosenberg aims to learn what he does not know. He writes about it here.



About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Steven Rosenberg published on January 28, 2008 5:00 PM.

Tired of Vista? Start the countdown to the next version of Windows was the previous entry in this blog.

Windows does something right is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Recent Comments

dbr on Question: Can we trust Google with our data?: Yes. They aren't getting any information I don't type into their websi ...

Powered by Movable Type 4.25

LXer

Links

Daily News technology
LXer
Distrowatch
Linus' Blog
David Pogue
BoingBoing
Linux Today
TuxRadar
Linux.com
Linux Planet
The Open Road
Linux Outlaws podcast
Dan Lynch
Fabian Scherschel
The VAR Guy
Larry the Free Software Guy
Chess Griffin
Linux Reality podcast
Desktop Linux
Practical Technology
Linux Devices
ZDNet
ZDNet U.K.
iTWire
CNet News
TechCrunch
The Register
Ars Technica
Reg Developer
Computerworld
Computerworld blogs
Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols at Computerworld
Debian
Planet Debian
Debian Forums
Debian News
debianHELP
debiantutorials.org
The Debian User
Wolfgang Lonien
Debian-News.net
Debian Administration
Debian Admin
Debian Weather
Ubuntu
Xubuntu
Kubuntu
Edubuntu
Gobuntu
Planet Ubuntu
Ubuntu Forums
Ubuntu Geek
Works With U
Dustin Kirkland
Ubuntu UK Podcast
Popey
gNewSense
CrunchBang Linux
OpenBSD
OpenBSD Journal
OpenBSD Ports
OpenBSD 101
Planet.OpenBSD.nu
jggimi's OpenBSD live CD
DaemonForums
BSDanywhere
Marc Balmer
Denny's OpenBSD blog
Polarwave's OpenBSD Tips and Tricks
Binary Updates for OpenBSD
Puppy Linux
Damn Small Linux
Tiny Core Linux
PCLinuxOS
Mandriva
Red Hat
Red Hat News
Red Hat Blogs
Red Hat: Truth Happens
Red Hat Magazine
CentOS
Planet CentOS
Fedora
Slackware
Slackbuilds
Robby's Slackware Packages
Slackblogs
dropline GNOME for Slackware
GNOME Slackbuild
GWARE - GNOME for Slackware
Wolvix
Zenwalk Linux
Vector Linux
Slax
Splack Linux — Slackware for Sparc
Nonux
How to Forge
marc.info BSD and Linux mailing list archive
FreeBSD
FreeBSD, the Unknown Giant
A Year in the Life of a BSD Guru
NetBSD
PC-BSD
DesktopBSD
DragonFlyBSD
DragonFlyBSD Digest
DesktopBSD
BSD Talk podcast
OpenSolaris
MilaX
BeleniX
DeLi Linux
Linux Loop
Electronista
Engadget
Gizmodo

Advertisement

Other blogs

Johnson Update in Inside USC with Scott Wolf
Has Bynum outgrown Kareem? in Inside the Lakers
Can the Angels just get to the end of this thing without an injury? in Farther Off the Wall
Neuheisel On: in Inside UCLA with Jon Gold
U.S. Roster for Final Two WCQ Announced in 100 Percent Soccer