Restaurant of the Week: Eureka Burger

51935-eureka 002.jpg
51936-eureka 005.jpg

Eureka Burger, 580 W. 1st St. (at Cornell), Claremont

When it was announced that Eureka Burger would take over the Claremont Packing House space formerly occupied by the high-end steakhouse Three Forks, I was skeptical. Sure, the economy had crashed, but going from steaks to hamburgers seemed like quite a comedown, even if Eureka has only two other locations, in Redlands and Fresno.

A peek at the online menu near the restaurant’s opening, however, showed off some mouth-watering burgers. And a recent visit with a group of friends proved Eureka to be a winner.

The wood-intensive interior still seems high end, there’s a bar with craft beer and there’s service at the tables, about half of which are outside on the deck.

Burgers range from $8.75 to $10.50. I had the Pearl Street Blues ($10), which is premium Angus ground chuck topped with melted bleu cheese, wild mushrooms, grilled onions and chipotle ketchup. It’s served on a sesame bun and was large enough to use a knife to cut it in half. The burger was, in a word, outstanding, among the best I can remember.

Everyone else liked their burgers as well. One got hers rare and remarked, “There’s not many places you can get a rare burger.” We also enjoyed a couple of orders of the enormous onion rings ($4.25), which use panko bread crumbs for a light batter. The menu also has salads and other sandwiches.

Eureka would seem to be in direct competition with the Back Abbey, another fancy burger and craft beer place two blocks away. Back Abbey is usually jam-packed, which I hope means both places can thrive because they both deserve to do so.

Eureka’s service was friendly. Servers all wore black T-shirts with varied slogans. One: “Respect Beer.”

Facebook Twitter Pinterest Plusone Linkedin Digg Reddit Stumbleupon Tumblr Email
  • John Clifford

    Also tried Eureka last week. Also had the Pearl Street Blues and a side of onion rings. (Great minds think alike.) I think I’ll be going back if for no other reason than there were some other menu items I’d love to try.

    [Me too. Some of the non-burger sandwiches sounded appealing but obviously a burger was the thing to get on the first visit. — DA]

  • How did I not know about this place?

    [It’s only been open a month. Don’t beat up on yourself. — DA]

  • Fred Henderson


    Could you put one of those great looking burgers in an envelope and sent it up here? It looks great! Yum!!


    Fred Henderson
    Everett, WA

    [Something tells me the burger wouldn’t look quite so good by the time you opened the envelope. — DA]

  • DAve

    Hey Dave!!

    Seen this label on the faux water tank on the south side of the 210 in San Dimas?
    Just thought congratulations were in order…

    [Heh heh. No, I hadn’t noticed that. Thanks, DAve. — DA]

  • DAve

    Only a man of great wealth and power could earn such an honor from the community…

    Speaking of which why don’t you become an Amazon affiliate so we can put some $$$ in your pocket?

    You and Instapundit…