Happy Columbus Day

| | Comments (10) |

Columbus isn't the revered figure he was in my childhood, or probably yours, but he gave us a holiday, whether we get the day off or not, and that's something, isn't it? Thanks, Chris.

10 Comments

Richard Pietrasz said:

It was Congress that made today a federal holiday.

Columbus was a genocidal, greedy slaver. His villainy greatly overshadows his accomplishments. Compared to Hitler, his scope of action was much smaller, but far more severe, and Hitler did pull Germany out of a truly severe depression. That great accomplishment is rightly overshadowed by his other evil deeds. Why should Columbus be treated differently? Is it because his attitudes of maximizing personal profit at any cost to others is so prevalent among the wealthy, including those who own the mainstream media, and specifically the parent corporation of the IEDB?

"Thanks, Chris" comes across as racist hate speech, and could easily be interpreted as support for the ongoing genocide done by the US military in Iraq and elsewhere.

DA, I suspect this was merely an insensitive remark on your part, enabled by the remnants of a public education system that considered genocide to be, at most, an unfortunate consequence of one of the largest armed robberies in human history.

["Easily"? -- DA]

Allan said:

Gratz to the guy who directed "Home Alone" and "Mrs. Doubtfire" along with a couple of films in the Potter series. Can't wait for Lucas Day or Spielberg Day though.

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001060/

Couldn't imagine the amount of vitriol you would have gotten if this had been about a holiday like Christmas. :)

[I could write "Thanks, Chris" but with an extra letter. -- DA]

Will Plunkett said:

I read an article that the citizens of Ohio's capital city believe this day's to celebrate them. Even more controversy now?

[And perhaps Philip Roth believes the day celebrates "Goodbye, Columbus." -- DA]

John Baugh said:

I guess before Columbus came along all the different Indian tribes got along peacefully. No fighting, no raiding, no war parties; just peaceful coexistence (this is where I wish there was a sarcasm font). If you want to know what America would be like had the Europeans not settled America, look no further than Africa.

DAve said:

Jeez Richard don't be such a tool -- Columbus discovering this land was by far the best thing that ever happened to everyone living here -- he brought the wheel and toilet paper to stone-age savages who still at that late date hadn't been able to come up with either. For inst-

If he was trying to commit genocide he sure wasn't very good at it-

Similarly if the U.S. military is trying to commit genocide in Iraq they must surely be very incompetent 'cuz they ain't killing very many people- but by all means why let logic and evidence stop you and your ilk when you're on a roll-

A vicious and totally predictable slander from some mom's-basement-dwelling slacker not worthy of polishing their boots-

It is YOU who shows the ravages of a depraved leftist brainwashing of a public-school education-

Yeah Dave stop your racist hate speech before Richard reports you to Attack Watch-

/SSSSSSSAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRRCCCCC

[Let's all remember, the headline began with the word "Happy." -- DA]

Ramona said:

Good grief!!

I really wanted to make a salient comment but words fail me.

Make a note of the date, folks. Words failing me doesn't happen very often.

[We'll await your next comment, Ramona. -- DA]

Dee said:

As my history teacher used to say: He may have discovered America, but it was the queen who gave him the money. LOL.

The "history" in the books my son is learning from are barely disguised racial rants from the other side. Yes, it DOES describe the native tribes as living in Eden and holding hands while singing Kumbaya. The book also describes the word "gringo" as a "slang term" for white people. I can't think of any "slang terms" for other races that would be called "slang," can you?

The truth is Columbus left orders, before returning to Spain, that the tribes were to be treated with the utmost respect. Unfortunately, he left some soldiers in charge who got in between two warring tribes (yes, the native tribes had discovered warfare without our help, thank you very much) and it all went downhill from there. There is evidence on one of the Caribbean islands, I forget which one, of one of Columbus' ships being taken apart and used as a fort, against the other, more angry, tribes.

I hope this doesn't start a hornet's nest, but the history being taught today is VERY different from what I was taught.

The Columbian Exchange said:

If you wanna see a smart, energetic discussion of Columbus, www.booktv.org is featuring an interview with author Charles Mann, author of "1493: Uncovering the World Columbus Created."

Mann is interviewed by free-thinking Mexican-American writer Richard Rodriguez, who has a few relatives in the area. Mann calls Columbus' "discovery" of America "The Columbian Exchange," where all corners of the world come back together.

Both insist Columbus Day should be celebrated as the start of the modern world. Rodriguez calls Columbus Day his "birthday," because he is a mestizo, descended from both Indians and Europeans.

Erik G. said:

I'll gladly trade all these controversial holidays for mandatory six-weeks of vacation!

Ygnacio Palomares said:

Ay Dios Mio! as a wise but somewhat misguided American said maany years ago...."Can't We All Just Get Along?"

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

About this blog

A roundup of news, history, food, travel and cultural items from around the Inland Valley.

About this blogger

A journalist for more than two decades, David Allen has been writing a column for the Daily Bulletin since 1997 and blogging since 2007.
He lives in Claremont.
E-mail David here or read columns here.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by David Allen published on October 10, 2011 8:20 AM.

Upland Winchell's sign is now art was the previous entry in this blog.

Jurassic Yard is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Recent Comments

Ygnacio Palomares on Happy Columbus Day: Ay Dios Mio! as a wi
Erik G. on Happy Columbus Day: I'll gladly trade al
The Columbian Exchange on Happy Columbus Day: If you wanna see a s
Dee on Happy Columbus Day: As my history teache
Ramona on Happy Columbus Day: Good grief!! I rea
DAve on Happy Columbus Day: Jeez Richard don't b
John Baugh on Happy Columbus Day: I guess before Colum
Will Plunkett on Happy Columbus Day: I read an article th
Allan on Happy Columbus Day: Gratz to the guy who
Richard Pietrasz on Happy Columbus Day: It was Congress that
Powered by Movable Type 4.25

Daily Bulletin Blogroll

Advertisement