(Re-)sizing up Yasiel Puig with the Dodgers.

Yasiel Puig

We can see now why the Dodgers gave Yasiel Puig all that money. We can also see why they won’t say where Puig will begin the season.

It’s only spring training, but Puig is the only Dodger to have played the maximum nine games. His .421 average (8-for-19) was 10th, and his 1.137 OPS ranked 13th, among all National League hitters when the day began. Only Luis Cruz (with 16) has more total bases than Puig’s 14. Only Cruz and Alex Castellanos have as many as Puig’s five RBIs.

Dodgers manager Don Mattingly went out of his way early in spring to downplay the importance of spring numbers. Sunday, he was asked (jokingly) whether Puig would be hitting second or seventh on Opening Day. Mattingly responded with a firm “don’t even get started.”

But if not Los Angeles, where will Puig be? General manager Ned Colletti had a chance to answer the question Sunday and demurred. Clearly, the jury is still out.

So far, the evidence says he’s capable of hitting major-league pitching. Maybe not pitching of the Justin Verlander/Clayton Kershaw/Felix Hernandez ilk, but major-league pitching nonetheless. Here’s a breakdown of Puig’s hits:

  • A double against Deunte Heath, who split last season between Triple-A (36 games) and the Chicago White Sox (3 games)
  • A single against Brian Schlitter, who split last season between Triple-A (37 games) and the Chicago Cubs (7 games)
  • A single against Brooks Raley, who split last season between Double-A (8 games), Triple-A (14) and the Chicago Cubs (5 games)
  • A single against Alberto Cabrera, who split last season between Double-A (23), Triple-A (13) and the Cubs (25)
  • A single against R.J. Alvarez, who split last season between Single-A and Florida Atlantic University
  • A double against Kevin Jepsen, who split last season between Triple- A (23 games) and the Angels (49 games)
  • A double against Oliver Perez, who split last season between Triple-A (22 games) and the Seattle Mariners (33 games)
  • A home run against Fernando Nieve, who spent all of last season in Triple-A.

A few months ago, Double-A Chattanooga seemed like Puig’s logical opening-day destination. Based on hitting ability alone, Puig looks closer to the majors than Double-A. Maybe the best reason to send Puig to Chattanooga is that it isn’t the Triple-A Pacific Coast League with its high-altitude ballparks, inflated batting averages and unrealistic expectations for what it takes to hit a home run in the majors. Puig gives the Dodgers a big (245-pound) reason for installing a humidor at Isotopes Park, which they hope will create a more Dodger Stadium-like atmosphere.

But suddenly it doesn’t seem impossible that Puig could be the 25th man on the Dodgers’ 25-man roster come Opening Day.

“Anything’s possible,” Mattingly said, “but I’m not going to start going into hypotheticals.”

As recently as last week’s game against the Angels, Puig showed a weakness for high fastballs out of the strike zone, but by Sunday the manager was complimenting Puig’s plate discipline. “He stayed in the strike zone pretty well,” Mattingly said. “He’s laid off some pitches and he’s fouled off some pitches on the fringes.”

If hitting were the only factor the Dodgers were evaluating him on, you might like Puig’s chances of sticking around. But hitting isn’t everything and Puig still has to show that he can run the bases intelligently. He still needs to show that he can hit better major-league pitching than Kevin Jepsen and Oliver Perez.

Puig will continue to get those chances in spring training and, as Mattingly said himself, “he’s fun to watch.”

This entry was posted in JP on the Dodgers, On The Farm by J.P. Hoornstra. Bookmark the permalink.

About J.P. Hoornstra

J.P. Hoornstra covers the Dodgers, Angels and Major League Baseball for the Orange County Register, Los Angeles Daily News, Long Beach Press-Telegram, Torrance Daily Breeze, San Gabriel Valley Tribune, Pasadena Star-News, San Bernardino Sun, Inland Valley Daily Bulletin, Whittier Daily News and Redlands Daily Facts. Before taking the beat in 2012, J.P. covered the NHL for four years. UCLA gave him a degree once upon a time; when he graduated on schedule, he missed getting Arnold Schwarzenegger's autograph on his diploma by five months.