Gail-Tz., Middle East Peace Envoy

| | Comments (3) |


King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia must have been using a strange blend in his hookah when he said that "Israel should give back the land seized 40 years ago" in exchange for peace.

First, let's discuss diction here. The land was not seized. It was won or acquired in a war. Has any historian ever noted England's King George III asking George Washington to give back the Thirteen Original Colonies after the War of Independence? How about Mexico asking the United States to return its gains after the Spanish American War? Though considering how things have been going, it wouldn't have made much of a difference anyway.

The bottom line is that nations do not return land won in a war, and the land is not "seized" as in stolen; it has been won and annexed fair and square.

This is why our current President, who seems like a nice enough fellow but has been operating along the lines of Alice in Wonderland, should not pressure the Israelis into dismantling their settlements because they have the right to annex land won in a war. But it is not the settlements that are bothering the Arabs and much of the free world anyway; it is the fact that there are more than enough Jews to hold a Mah Jong game anywhere. The Jews could set up a homeland in Alaska, and the Arabs would walk, fly and trod there just to say that they are annoying them and are at the root of their problems.

Further down the watering hole, Alice also praised Palestinian Prime Minister, Mahmoud Abbas, for standing fast in unity talks with Hamas, like any rational person would want to stand in unity with an outfit whose chief goals are victimhood, reproduction or munitions.

Let's look at what other presidents would have done. George Washington tried negotiating with the British, but when he realized that they were dead set on their course, he set out along his path and a great nation came to be born. How about Abraham Lincoln? He tried talking to General Davis and Lee, but when they set off along the path of slavery, he'd had enough and fired the first shot on Fort Sumter. The end result, probably had something to do with how Obama became president, but that will be for a later discussion. The bottom line is that there is a time and place for everything. There is a time for talk, for making nice; there is a time for being namby-pamby and a time for making war. And this is it.

Alas, the ever-loving peacenicks at Hamas have managed to tick off more than the Israelis. In an effort to rein them in, the Palestinian police recently raided a compound and bumped off about six of them, and true to form, the terrorist outfit promised "tough and harsh reprisal."

I may have been wrong about things before, but my prediction is that someday one of their air heads will wind up pressing the wrong button and will turn the whole lot of them into fish chum.

3 Comments

Craig Griffith Author Profile Page said:

>The Jews could set up a homeland in Alaska, and the Arabs would walk, fly and trod there just to say that they are annoying them.

While the Arab world, by and large, is not necessarily fond of Jews, it is mostly anti-Israeli sentiment that is at issue here. If the Jewish homeland were in Alaska, then the only people complaining would be the Inuit, Aleut, and other native peoples potentially displaced or confronted by a culture foreign to their own. Anti-Israeli sentiment may be nurtured by good old-fashioned anti-Semitism, but it is mostly the claim to lands that are also considered holy to Islam (which happens in the backyard of the middle Eastern Arab world) that makes the blood of anti-Israeli Arabs boil. And while it is true that Israel is unlikely to dissolve of its own volition, it is also true that it will often to have to fight wars, declared or undeclared, to retain its claim on the highly disputed land of which it is constituted.

Also, I'm not sure if you were making an oblique reference to it already, but I do highly recommmend the novel The Yiddish Policemen's Union, written by Michael Chabon, which is set in an alternate timeline in which a Jewish homeland was, in fact, set up in Sitka, Alaska.

Rob Asghar Author Profile Page said:

Good points, Craig. I believe Gail-Tz is right about some ways in which the Arabs & Palestinians have been unreasonable in their own expectations, but I'm curious to hear Gail-Tz address how Israel can manage to retain its identity as a Jewish nation without spinning off the Palestinian population into a separate state before they become a majority within Israel.

Gail-Tzipporah Saunders Author Profile Page said:

Honey, that is the million dollar question, which this wanna-be envoy doesn't have the answer to.

Leave a comment

Friendly Fire comments

Due to the huge amount of spam, commenters on Friendly Fire must now register with the site and sign in to leave a comment.

Creating a Movable Type commenting account is easy: After you click on the "comments" link in a blog post (or are already in an individual blog entry), click "sign in." When you are at the Movable Type "sign-in to comment" screen, after the words "Not a member?" click "Sign up!"

You will be asked for a minimal amount of information, including an e-mail address, which we need to verify the account.

If you sign up and for some reason don't get a return e-mail confirming your new account, please e-mail Steven Rosenberg at steven.rosenberg@
dailynews.com, and he will activate your account and notify you. He can also help you with any other issues regarding signing up for or leaving comments on the blog.

Tip: To ensure that you receive the confirmation e-mail when you do sign up to comment on the blog, BEFORE you sign up, put the e-mail address online@langnews.com in your mail program's address book. That way, the message from the server to confirm your account won't get lost in your spam file.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Gail-Tzipporah Saunders published on June 2, 2009 11:50 AM.

Obama Might Need to Show ID in More Places than East Harlem was the previous entry in this blog.

Does Nuance Matter...? is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Recent Comments

Gail-Tzipporah Saunders on Gail-Tz., Middle East Peace Envoy: Honey, that is the million dollar question, which this wanna-be envoy ...

Rob Asghar on Gail-Tz., Middle East Peace Envoy: Good points, Craig. I believe Gail-Tz is right about some ways in whi ...

Craig Griffith on Gail-Tz., Middle East Peace Envoy: >The Jews could set up a homeland in Alaska, and the Arabs would walk, ...

Powered by Movable Type 4.25

Advertisement

Other blogs

Cole Of The Day in Inside USC with Scott Wolf
Rambis interests T-Wolves in Inside the Lakers
Ask Jim Fox, 2009 in Inside the Kings
Tuesday's Column: The Beckham Experiment (Chapter 3) in 100 Percent Soccer
Giving communities power over schools in The Sausage Factory