My Own Arizona Hypocrisy

| | Comments (0) |

I am relieved that the Federal Judge has stayed most of Arizona 1070, the ill-conceived immigration bill that puts every brown-skinned person in peril. I hope that the stay becomes permanent. I find it hateful that skin color, clothing or accent could ever be considered probable cause to suspect someone's right to be here. Yes, we do have a right, an obligation, to control our borders. And yes, the Feds have done a very bad job of it. I do understand the frustration of some at such failure. However, the passion of the mob, however righteous the motive, is no substitute for our Constitution. Crime is a problem, but vigilantes are not the answer.

However, I do have to confess to an epiphany this weekend that made me feel like a self-righteous hypocrite. Having spent some time being mad at Arizona, writing criticism of their law, their impulses and their attitude, I was brought up short when coming home from visiting friends near San Diego. As we drove through the Immigration Checkpoint, about 75 miles north of the Mexican border, I remembered every other time I had driven through. Not once was I ever stopped. The uniformed immigration agent just looked in the window and passed us through. The only people we ever saw pulled over to the side had brown skin.

We have done for decades in California what I objected to Arizona doing--and I never really noticed. I saw but I didn't see. I may have to call off my boycott and smug sense of superiority, for I am guilty of tolerating what I find intolerable in another state. Whether the stopping of brown skinned people by the state or the federal government, the 14th Amendment promises equal protection and due-process for all. Most of us would agree that "driving while black" should not be probable cause to be stopped by the police. Well, living while brown should not create the demand to produce your papers or else.

We could fix our immigration problem easily if we had the will to put the burden on those who employ undocumented people. But we haven't the will. And so we take out our frustration based on color, dress and accent. This may be our American tradition but constitutionally, this is un-American.
©2010 Jonathan Dobrer
www.Dobrer.com


Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Jonathan Dobrer published on July 28, 2010 3:57 PM.

Those Embarrassing Leaks was the previous entry in this blog.

L'Affaire Breitbart is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Recent Comments

Powered by Movable Type 4.25

Search this blog

Loading

Advertisement

Other blogs

Galaxy to play TJ in preseason game in San Diego in 100 Percent Soccer
Hobbi picks USC; what's next for UCLA? in Inside UCLA with Jon Gold
Athletes Touch tourney on Monday in In The Rough
Redistricting commission hires former Chick aide in The Sausage Factory
Another Name in Inside USC with Scott Wolf