On Prosecuting Julian Assange

| | Comments (0) |

While prosecuting Assange is not quite as bad an idea as trying Khalid Sheikh Mohammad in New York City, it comes perilously close. First of all, Gail is wrong that a reason to prosecute him is that he is aware that he did something wrong. I doubt that it is factually true. I see most bad things done by people with unreflective certainty of the goodness of their acts. That he may be an idealist believing that he is carrying out the Lord's work should have no bearing on our desire to bring him to trial. I'm pretty sure that John Wilkes Booth and Sirhan Sirhan were sure of their cause.

Then there is the question of the charges against him. If he stole the information, then he should indeed be tried on espionage. But if he merely received it, Mr. Holder will have a hell of a time distinguishing his actions--however damaging or odious you may believe them to be--from all our legitimate purveyors of news and information. How will he differentiate Assange's reporting of the leaks from that of the New York Times?

If his crime is a hybrid and he encouraged the theft of government information or paid for it, there may be a case. But that is different from what now the case appears to be. I think that absent his personal involvement in stealing the information that our media will line up solidly behind his right to blow the whistle on our diplomatic hypocrisies.

The most interesting part of this case is the suspicion that all of these leaked cables and military action reports could not have come from one annoyed (even treasonous) Private First Class. Assange may well have other sources and resources. Personally, I smell a state actor behind this, and when we look at what state benefits the most from our embarrassment, Russia pops to the surface. Whether Assange is a knowing agent or unconscious dupe, the final story may well involve Russia operating through Estonian hackers.


©2010 Jonathan Dobrer
www.Dobrer.com


Leave a comment

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Jonathan Dobrer published on December 15, 2010 9:53 PM.

Julian Assange vs. Perez Hilton was the previous entry in this blog.

No Case Against WikiLeaks Assange is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Recent Comments

Powered by Movable Type 4.25

Search this blog

Loading

Advertisement

Other blogs

Galaxy to play TJ in preseason game in San Diego in 100 Percent Soccer
Hobbi picks USC; what's next for UCLA? in Inside UCLA with Jon Gold
Athletes Touch tourney on Monday in In The Rough
Redistricting commission hires former Chick aide in The Sausage Factory
Another Name in Inside USC with Scott Wolf