Top 4: Mel (oh) D.

If they don't win IDOL...
they'd be great at:

sem: uhh, not exciting
sem: she was better last week
fred: bland. no edge.
sem: that face...stop actin scared Melinda!
fred: she's a fake. she knows she can sing and she's acting all "i'm scared and goofy."
sem: or that might just be her face. period. a look more suited for a kindergarten teacher or something...