Alaina Whittaker
Personally, I think Alaina did better job singing "Hopelessly Devoted to You" in the elimination show last night than in her first performance -- the show that really counted. Last night's performance had so much more emotion, feeling, heart, and purity. She didn't try to finesse or diva-up the song. Even her big notes were so much better than the first time around.
First night:
Elimination night (this video also has the "I can't sing!" yelp):
What do you think?