Results tagged “Sun” from CLICK

Sam Varghese of iTWire finds a whole lot wrong with just about every aspect of Sun's new, somewhat-but-not-so open desktop initiative (still dubbed in some circles Project Indiana):

Project Indiana is headed by Ian Murdock who started the Debian GNU/Linux project in 1993 and led it for three years. After leaving Debian, Murdock started another distribution called Progeny based on Debian, but that shut shop after a while. People often have the perception that if one touch turns something into gold, then it works every time. Sadly, such is not the case.

There has been some acrimony over the fact that Murdock's project seems to have appropriated the name OpenSolaris. So much so, that one well-known participant in the OpenSolaris project, Roy Fielding of Apache HTTP Server Project fame, quit in disgust earlier this year. He had this to say, in part: "What is the point of creating the OpenSolaris Community governance if the community isn't even allowed to decide what is called OpenSolaris? This isn't an abstract discussion of trademarks. It is the fundamental basis for making technical decisions of any kind for the project."

Commenting on his departure, Emily Ratliff of IBM's Linux Technology Centre pointed out that until that point there had been 578 patches contributed to the OpenSolaris project, a rate of 0.6 patches a day. "Linus (Torvalds, the creator of the Linux kernel) gets more patches while he is brushing his teeth than OpenSolaris gets in a week. Despite Roy's efforts to build a real community, contributing to OpenSolaris always has been and seemingly always will be, corporate welfare," she commented.

And, she added: "For me, the realization (sic) that Sun just doesn't get it, and never will, was crystallized (sic) the day I was turned away from an OpenSolaris Users' Group meeting for refusing to sign an NDA."

I have no firsthand knowledge of all the community acrimony over OpenSolaris. And I do want there to be more than one -- and more than two or three -- viable open-source operating systems out there, so I'm rooting big time for OpenSolaris to find its legs and really start making an impact.

Even though the current version hasn't worked for me, I have enjoyed using MilaX and will try Belenix as soon as I'm able. And I'm game for the next rendition of OpenSolaris whenever it's released. Hopefully Sun and its community (such as it is, or becomes) can right the ship and start making some waves out there.

I don't follow Sun or OpenSolaris all that closely, although I have tried Project Indiana, been intrigued by a "Damn Small" take on OpenSolaris, and generally think that Sun is doing all the right things to survive and thrive in the post-proprietary world.

I still want an old Sun SPARCstation, but I can't seem to get that hooked up ... but be that as it may, OpenSolaris -- the open-source, community-fueled version of Sun's Unix-like Solaris operating system -- has been officially launched, as I read in Desktop Linux.

Officially launched? Who knew they hadn't already done that. The OpenSolaris project gets a lot of credibility due to Debian founder Ian Murdock's shepherding of the project in his current capacity at Sun, but it has lost a bit of that credibility over recent months due to a power struggle of sorts -- and I really don't know much about it, so don't rely on me for any understanding whatsoever of said struggle -- between Sun and members of the OpenSolaris community.

My experience was also much worse than that of the reviewer at Phoronix.