ABOUT

Pasadena -- news, politics and gossip.

Send tips, rumors, rants to Fred Ortega fred.ortega@sgvn.com.

SGVN.com
Subscribe to RSS feed

Recent Comments

Powered by
Movable Type 4.01

« The law cuts both ways | Main | A place for friends »

CTRL-C, CTRL-V Journalism

Real reporting got'ya down? Too hard?

Not so! Especially with these handy Internets at our fingertips. Not when you can re-report the actual work done by actual reporters. Except would-be plagiarists are usually savvy enough to rewrite the copy and make a phone call of their own, even throw in a few "such and such told us in an exclusive interview."

Which makes for an entertaining (some might assert troubling?) lapse by Pasadena Now, as recounted by our Public Editor Lawrence of Wilson:

Rewriting someone else's stories is one thing. Simply stealing them word for word is another. We all know that the one-man-band news site Pasadena Now doesn't have much staff, whether in Bangalore or Pasadena. That's why they can't cover the news like a professional organization. It's tough all over, but our science and health writer Elise Kleeman, a Caltech grad and extraordinary professional journalist, worked hard recently to get the long covered-up story about a huge back-pay settlement Huntington Hospital has been ordered by a court to pay its nurses.

Here's a couple excerpts for comparison's sake -- Larry posted both stories in full.

From our by-lined story by science reporter Elise Kleeman:

Superior Court Judge William MacLaughlin, who ruled in September that the hospital was attempting to dodge overtime laws, sided with the employees again in accepting their calculation of the underpaid wages.

Huntington lawyers had argued the restitution amount should be decreased by approximately $20 million.

The class-action lawsuit, filed by four former Huntington nurses, charged that the hospital failed to pay adequate overtime for 2,117 employees between 1999 and 2004.

"We're very pleased," said Joseph Antonelli, lawyer for the nurses. "I think it's going to be a landmark decision because there hasn't been a trial court decision on this issue before."

And from Now's "staff report:"

Superior Court Judge William MacLaughlin, who ruled in September that the hospital was attempting to dodge overtime laws, sided with the employees again in accepting their calculation of the underpaid wages.

Huntington lawyers had argued the restitution amount should be decreased by approximately $20 million.

The class-action lawsuit, filed by four former Huntington nurses, charged that the hospital failed to pay adequate overtime for 2,117 employees between 1999 and 2004.

"We're very pleased," said Joseph Antonelli, lawyer for the nurses. "I think it's going to be a landmark decision because there hasn't been a trial court decision on this issue before."

Score one for these fine, vast Interwebs!

Comments

Is Elise Kleeman moonlighting for Pasadena Now? Heh. Does she get to keep all the money?
I guess the Pasadena Now owes Elise Kleeman some back pay of her own.
I guess the much more 'savvy' (or is it sneaky?) Singleton Empire knows how to work it better...a reporter in Long Beach writes the story and the rest of the Singleton publications run it as their own...will this hypothetical Long Beach reporter get a bump on his/her salary? I very much doubt it....There's a double standard going on here....
"Rick" -- Apples and oranges. One is theft of intellectual property and violation of copyright law. The other is bottom-lined oriented "synergy." Reporters aren't compensated when our stories get picked up by the wires, but you can bet our names are at the top and the newspaper gets credit.

Post a comment

The Roll

Altadena Above it All
District 6 blog
District of Sexy
Eye Level Pasadena
Feminary
Foothill Cities
LA Observed
Miss Havisham's Tea Party
Pasadena Conversations
Pasadena Pundit
ProctorForMayor
Pasadena Political Underbelly
Stonehill News
West Coast Grrlie Blather
Reporter 'G'-Scott shares 'precise thoughts for modern living'

Our SGVN blogs

Hallway Monitor
Caroline An's experiences the Pasadena Unified School District.
The Public Eye
SGVN Public Editor Larry Wilson muses on life, newspapering and the Velvet Underground.
Scott Galetti Talks Prep Sports What else is there to say? Scott's a cool guy who posts about local prep sports.
Crime Scene
Tribune crime guy Frank Girardot wants to know where the bodies are and what they're stuffed into.
Editors' Corner
Edward Barrera and Kate Kealey, las editors libres, reflect on the news in general with a dash of newsroom insidering.
Leftovers from City Hall
More city hall news and tidbits from around the Valley, brought to you by reporters Jennifer McLain and Tania Chatila.
Fred Robledo Talks Prep Sports
Tribune sports dude Fred Robledo's monster prep sports blog.

ADVERTISEMENT

Copyright Notice | Privacy Policy | Information
For more local Southern California news:
Copyright © 2007 Los Angeles Newspaper Group