UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident

| | Comments (81) |

IN A STAR-NEWS ONLINE POLL...
Should a Monrovia High School track coach have sought to have a rival pole vaulter disqualified from a key match for wearing a bracelet?

2,142 total votes
YES: 331 votes, or 15.45 percent
NO: 1,811 votes, or 84.54 percent

RELATED LINKS

Pasadena Star-News: Laird caught in national radar screen after controversial disqualification

Pasadena Star-News: Jewelry snafu costs South Pasadena

Sports Illustrated: Where's the sportsmanship? Girl disqualified for wearing bracelet

By Miguel A. Melendez, Staff Writer

The controversial ruling that disqualified a South Pasadena High School pole vaulter for wearing a friendship bracelet during a dual track meet will stand, and no action will be taken against the coach who pointed out the infraction.

Monrovia High School Principal Darvin Jackson said track team co-coach Mike Knowles' job is not in jeopardy.

"We just needed to look at all the facts to see what actually transpired," Jackson said. "That's what we did with (South Pasadena coach) P.J. (Hernandez) and (assistant coach) C.B. (Richards). We wanted to see if there was any malicious intent, and it was decided that was not the case, and all parties agreed."

Administrators, athletic directors and track coaches from Monrovia and South Pasadena high schools had an hour-long meeting Wednesday evening to discuss what happened at the April 29 track meet that decided the girls' Rio Hondo League championship.

In a joint statement released Thursday, both schools agreed Monrovia would keep its first-ever league title and no action would be taken against Knowles, who noted the infraction after South Pasadena's Robin Laird cleared 7 feet, 6 inches to seemingly win the league title for the Tigers.

News of Knowles' challenge and Laird's disqualification has sparked a heated national debate among commentators, bloggers and the media.

CLICK ON THREAD TO CONTINUE READING

"Despite exploring alternative outcomes for the league championship," the schools' statement
read, "South Pasadena High School and Monrovia High School have concluded together, and agreeably, that Monrovia will retain the Rio Hondo League Championship.

"It is evident from the actions of the school leaders that the spirit of sportsmanship and camaraderie remains strong in the Rio Hondo League and between Monrovia and South Pasadena high schools. We wish both teams continued success, representing the (Rio Hondo League) as a united front competing in the CIF-Southern Section Prelims this weekend."

Both coaching staffs unanimously agreed with the ruling by the National Federation that jewelry is not to be worn during competition, but took issue with the definition of "jewelry." Laird has worn a bracelet made of cloth since November.

"Although the `jewelry' rule is a controversial one," the statement read, "we deemed that it was not our position to interpret the rule to benefit either team. Therefore, CIF-SS was contacted. They responded by defining jewelry as, `anything that adorns the body.'

"While this is not the way any team would have liked to win, it was also the feeling of the group that had this incident occurred at a different time in the meet, the outcome would have remained the same, likely without the dramatics leading to such media coverage."

miguel.melendez@sgvn.com


81 Comments

High quality info here! Keep up the great work. I love the feelings being expressed.

I am not in truth positive if top tactics have emerged around stuff similar to that, except I am definite that your huge job is visibly recognized. I was questioning if you offer some subscription toward your RSS feeds as I would be extremely concerned.

High quality info here! Keep up the great work. I love the feelings being expressed.

Collections said:

Wow, amazing blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy.

Kudos to you! This is a really good blog here and I love your style of writing. How did you get so good at blogging?

Dreamin. I love blogging. You all express your feelings the right way, because they are your feeling, focus on your blog it is great.

Forum said:

Interesting thoughts here. I appreciate you taking the time to share them with us all. It's people like you that make my day :)

I love the way you write and also the theme on your blog. Did you code this yourself or was it done by a professional? I'm very very impressed.

Keep focusing on your blog. I love how we can all express our feelings. This is an extremely nice blog here :)

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

I agree with your thoughts here and I really love your blog! I've bookmarked it so that I can come back & read more in the future.

Luis said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

Luis said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

Mary said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

Self said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

James said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

Self said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

James said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

Self said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

Mark said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

Luis said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd like to ask you in private, ideally by email. How can I reach you?

Organic Food said:

Wow, amazing blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy.

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think...

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think...

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think...

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think...

instantempo said:

Uhm... I don't really know what to think...

Interesting layout on your blog. I really enjoyed reading it and also I will be back to read more in the future.

I would like to start my own blog one day. This was a really nice blog that you made here. Keep up the success :P

instantempo said:

Im sorry to ask again, but have you an email or something. I-d like to ask you a few things. it-s quite important. thanks /instantempo

instantempo said:

Im sorry to ask again, but have you an email or something. I-d like to ask you a few things. it-s quite important. thanks /instantempo

instantempo said:

Im sorry to ask again, but have you an email or something. I-d like to ask you a few things. it-s quite important. thanks /instantempo

instantempo said:

Im sorry to ask again, but have you an email or something. I-d like to ask you a few things. it-s quite important. thanks /instantempo

I am extremely impressed with your writing skills and also with the layout on your blog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the nice quality writing, it's rare to see a nice blog like this one these days.. :)

instantempo said:

Hi, how can I contact you? Do you have an email, a facebook profile or something? I need to ask you something, if I may. thanks. in the meantime, have a nice day. -instantempo

This is the kind of blog I would like to have.

Befitting the action words in the text, the font size bounces from small to large, adding to the energetic tone (as do a healthy number of monkeys). An accompanying DVD louboutin shoes an animated video of the song.

I just couldnt leave your website before telling you that I really enjoyed the useful information you offer to your visitors… Will be back often to check up on new posts

It is important to set clear expectations and measurable goals before you can start coaching and mentoring. How can your coaching and mentoring be effective when you have not established any expectations and goals?

I absolutely agree while using first commentator, so it truly is not a fake. But I heard a lot of various opinion on this topic.

WILDCAT Behind The Orange Curtain said:

What ever happened to 'No Harm ~ No Foul'?
And for THIS 'infraction' to be called at THIS time?!?

I 100% agree with a 'rule is a rule', a 'law is a law', a 'promise is a promise', etc. etc. etc. However, conveniently located between rules/rules, laws/laws, promises/promises, etc/etc, is Discretion.

Especially HERE since the 'violation' had been occurring for a time period prior to the date in question.

AND for the California Interscholastic Federation - Southern Section to make a 'supreme court' revelation by defining jewelry as, "anything that adorns the body". GOD forbid an athlete would wear a Spider-Man Band-Aid!!!

MY KIDS GO TO MONROVIA said:

All of you that are HATTER HATTER on Coach Knowles can kiss all of our FriendShip bracelet wearing A****. Whatever already beat us then next year, but don"t wear any BRACELETS.....

Rams09 said:

Pretty petty of Monrovia's coach to do, but a rule's a rule. Referees and coaches always remind players of rules and I'm sure she's probably heard one reminder of it before. The Mtown coach should have just warned her, so that's pretty unsportsmanlike of him to do.

I remember at a track meet almost two years ago I saw a top shotputter at the SGV Invite and he put tape on the bottom of his shoe because the ring was absolutely slippery and he was disqualified. Athletes normally get warnings about jewelery or anything of the sort beforehand and I feel it should have been the same in this case

Anonymous said:

If Coach Knowles cannot win on the field of athletics, it is nice to know that he can hide behind a rulebook. He ambushed this girl, knowing full well the minor violation would disqualify her. It is sad and it sends a terrible message. I would look for some retaliation next year on Knowles. Monrovia will have an asterisk by this victory in the books. He has tarnished the sport and his team by acting in such a petty manner.

The rule is there, and it is there for safety reasons, but we might as well disqualify Usain Bolt for wearing gold shoes. That is the kind of pettiness the world does not need.

to it's a joke said:

The point isn't rather the test is beneficial or not. It's the fact that it is a rule for coaches to follow and Coach Knowles didn't do it. Same thing as the bracelet. They both don't have anything to do with performance, but if we are going to pick at every rule, than let's be consistant.

to it's a joke said:

The point isn't rather the test is beneficial or not. It's the fact that it is a rule for coaches to follow and Coach Knowles didn't do it. Same thing as the bracelet. They both don't have anything to do with performance, but if we are going to pick at every rule, than let's be consistant.

it's a joke said:

Whoever it is that keeps bringing up this "CIF test", let it go already. The CIF test is a joke. Anyone with half a brain can pass it. The test is just something CIF uses to cover their butt. It has no bearing on what kind of coach you are.

Hey Miguel said:

Why doesn't someone check and make sure Coach Knowles has taken his CIF test? Last I heard he had not. If that is the case, then he can call that rule on himself, dq all of his dual meet results, scratch his kids from CIF Finals, and take responsibility for his lack of professionalism. South Pas would have their Championship back, ALL rules would be followed, and Coach Knowles would be redeemed for being consistent with enforcing every rule that he has learned in the last 30 years, not just when it involves his team winning. Why not call up the CIF office and do a follow up on that rule?

joke said:

Any fact that comes out now, doesn't hide the FACT that the Monrovia coach is a douche. How lame bro. If I had a kid on that team, I'd pull her out of that sport because I would hate for my daughter to have to look at his lame face, although my daughter, like Webster's dictionary, would probably know that jewelry is made of precious metals and gemstones...not thread. Cry some more.

91030 said:

While I have always had the utmost respect for Mr Lamaster and most of the regular Monrovia commentators on this blog, I do have to say that the recent comments appearing to "blame" Coach Hernandez and Ms. Laird disappoint and show some diminished class with respect to the situation.

First, the issue which has rightfully inflamed most readers and writers is not whether the string bracelet was jewlrey and was a correct basis for disqualification, but rather whether the actions of the Monrovia coach were proper sportsmanship under the circumstances or mere gamesmanship. Read the Sports Illustrated article, which starts off with the description of a D2 college playoff softball game where the losing team only lost because they did not follow "the rule" making a player circle the bases after her walkoff homerun, and carried her around after she broke her foot. Not enforcing that "rule", to technically win a game they had lost demonstrated the type of sportsmanship most Americans admire, and which the vast majority (based on the threads from around the country) did not see taking place here. Technically right or wrong, no sportsmanship award was won by Coach Knowles here. That being said I must also say that I completely respect and admire the abilities and sportsmanship of every other Monrovia coach I have seen over the years in FB, BB, Baseball and soccer.

Second, actual criticism of Coach Hernandez and Ms. Laird is completely off base and unwarranted. Neither has publicly attacked or blamed Monrovia or its coach, or asked to change the result. Based on multiple comments attributed to Ms. Laird, including in yesterdays LA Times Lopez article, she took full responsibility and demonstrated great class. Looking at the facts, she had worn the offending "bracelet" throughout the entire season of several previous meets and no official or coach deemed it a violation. No one had questioned Coach Hernandez about it, and so therefore it was a non issue, with no one believing it was violation, until the Monrovia coach made it one. Coach Hernandez did, and has always reminded everyone of the rule and that is shown by the fact that real jewlrey is constantly removed before meets. Coach Hernandez is one of the best, brightest and most caring of his athletes coaches I have seen. Attacking him to excuse the less than sportsmanlike actions of his opposition is simply wrong.

anonymous said:

goteamgo: That would be pretty stupid!!! Let it go already!!! The only person it would drive crazy, is YOU.....when it brings negative attention to south pas.

goteamgo said:

I have a suggestion next season for the South Pas track team when the meet Monrovia.

Have one of their athletes (or better yet an art student) get a few felt-tip markers. Take these markers and draw images of jewelry on the entire track team; take the felt marker and draw a bracelet, maybe a ring, an ankle bracelet, a neck chain, and maybe place a couple of dots on the ears for fake earrings.

I guarantee it will drive the entire Monrovia coaching staff crazy, trying to determine if it is real or fake. Could be some fun.

Amused Reader said:

Since when is a bracelet made of cloth? The term bracelet makes it sound like some gold chain. To have a title stripped, as well as an individual title stripped over that means track athletes should no longer be able to wear knee braces or elbow pads. Or shoelaces. What a joke. And for those who say move on, the only way to move on is for the league and CIF to overturn their stupid decision and give the team that earned the title the title.

Didn't WE all know about the Rule, BE HONEST ! said:


WHAT ABOUT PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY. ROBIN FAILED THAT TEST COUNTLESS TIMES

FINALLY THAT ASPECT OF THIS STORY IS COMING TO LIGHT

EVERY COMPETITOR BUT ROBIN? WHY?

I'm sure other competitors rolled their eyes when they saw her bracelet at every single track meet. If you've ever been to a Track Meet her bracelet would have stood out like a sore thumb, to the untrained eye probably but to the experienced there, for sure.

Better yet, if we're all honest with ourselves we all know when we read the story we all said it to ourselves...

"NOT THE JEWELRY RULE!!!!"...because we all knew!!!!

All of us...and yet Robin faiied her team, and yes she knew.

Sorry.

Proud To Be A Monrovian said:

I certainly feel for Robin Laird in this situation but my attention was drawn to the statement in this article that "Laird has worn a bracelet made of cloth since November." Steve Lopez made the same comment in his column in today's LA Times as her justification of why she didn't think to take it off. If that was the case, she is admitting that she wore that bracelet in all her prior meets this season. That calls into question all her individual victories and her school's meet placements as well. I don't fault Robin, catching and correcting rules violations is the job of her coach, not her. In this case it is not Mike Knowles that should be publically flogged for doing his job too well, it is Pasadena's P.J. Hernandez for failing in his responsibilities.

Hal Lamaster said:

The coach that should be "talked to" by administrators is the South Pas coach. It is his responsibility to know the no jewelry rule. Surprisingly, he failed to make sure his athlete took off the bracelet ALL SEASON. It came back to bite him.
This situation (and second place) belongs to the South Pas athlete and coach.

Let's get real said:

I can fully understand both sides of this argument, but to think Coach Knowles was even being considered for disciplinary action is absurd. Also, please don't throw around statements like "Robin Laird IS THE BEST VAULT JUMPER IN THE SG VALLEY AND IN SOUTH PASADENA HIGH SCHOOL HISTORY PERIOD." She may be the best in SP school history as I am not familiar with their school records, but there are several girls from both Temple City and Arcadia who vault much higher. This is an open forum but remember that it in one thing to be ignorant, it is quite another to open your mouth and prove it to the world.

Really? said:

I have a suggestion. Actually I have two.

First, why don't we all just move on. I've thought long and hard about this. Who's right, who's wrong. And after days of deliberation I came to the conclusion that I don't really give a cr@p.

Second, TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK!!!

LET HAVE FUN ! said:


TOO FUNNY ... NO BRACELET IN THIS ACTION SHOT EITHER?

WAS IT PHOTOSHOPPED OUT OR WAS IT A MEDICAL REMOVAL?

HILARIOUS.

TOO BAD COACH KNOWLES IS BEING CRUCIFIED.

HOW ABOUT AN ACT OF DEFIANCE AND EVERY SOUTH PASADENA ATHLETE SHOW UP TO THE NEXT MEET WITH LIARD RUBBERR BANDS AND REFUSE TO TAKE THEM OFF.

HOW ABOUT ALL MONROVIA TEAM MEMBERS REFUSE TO PUT THE LEAGUE CHAMPIONSHIP PATCHES ON THEIR JACKETS

HOW ABOUT THE MONROVIA MARCHES DOWN FOOTHILL AND PRESENTS THEIR PATCHES TO THE SOUTH PASADENA TEAM

ANY ONE ELSE HAVE ANY SUGGESTIONS?

tracknut said:

Why should the coach be disciplined? Coaches all during the year and before each track meet are reminded that jewelry shall not be worn. The article mentions that the vaulter started down the runway and stopped. She might have also violated the two minute rule which no one else is mentioning.

ALL LIARD'S TEAM MATES HELD UP THEIR END OF TEH NO JEWELRY RULE, WHY DIDN'T SHE? said:


What a whiney little girl. She knew the rules and ignored them all season. She coaches knew the rules and ignored them all season. Her team mates knew the rules and ignored them for her. Was Liard the only athlete who wore a thread bracelet or is she the only one who didn't take it off. These bracelets are popular right now but only Liard refused to take off the bracelet? Better still when all the athletes do the "TIME TO TAKE OFF THE JEWELRY THING" she held out. The timing might have sucked but Liard knows in her heart that every single athlete held true to that rule, she didn't! END OF STORY...SHE LET HER TEAM MATES DOWN.

Now the school takes the stance that somehow the COACH might face DISCIPLINE...FOR ENFORCING A RULE!

WE HAVE LOST OUR WAY PEOPLE!

ENOUGH ! ALREADY !!!!

Maybe she'll tell this story all years to come but hopefully some one in the group will say..."WHO DOESN'T KNOW THE JEWELRY RULE?"

Anonymous said:

This guy is a jackass... period.

Amused Reader said:

Ummm, Monrovia got handed the league title, not South Pasadena. South Pas earned the title and had it taken away over a piece of string. Is it football season yet? Too much track talk. Who cares?

paul said:

Im just glad Track & field finally got mentioned,one of the great individual sports, that doesnt get the recongnition it deserves

Witness said:

Good call! Knowles should not be disciplined for pointing out a rules violation and South Pasadena should not be handed the Rio Hondo League title. CIF rules are there for a reason.

That said, it does not deter from the pettiness of his protest....the damage is done-Knowles will forever be remembered as the candy a$$ coach who could not man up and handle the defeat. His "win at all cost" perspective clearly makes him "the biggest loser."

Sorry coach, you have lost our respect!

Agent_football said:

Seriously!, WHY ARE MAKING A PROBLEM OVER A STUPID BRACELET. SERIOUSLY WHO IS MAKING A BIG DEAL OUT OF THIS CIF, OFFICIALS, COACHES FREAKIN RIDICULOUS. I DONT KNOW WHAT THIS WORLD IS COMING INTO. IF THIS GIRL Robin Laird, CLEARED A YAO MING HEIGHT OF A JUMP THIS SHOULD NOT MATTER. DID THE JEWLERY HURT HER OR WHAT IS THE PROBLEM, DID SOMEONE GIVE IT TO HER SO WHAT SHE CLEARED THE FREAKIN JUMP AND SHE SHOULD BE DQ OR WHATEVER SHE GETTING FOR IT. SERIOUSLY, Robin Laird TO ME IS THE BEST VAULT JUMPER IN THE SG VALLEY AFTER THIS INCIDENT, IF I EVER MET I'D SHAKE HER HAND AND SAY GOOD JOB YOU ARE A STAR ATHLETE AND PEOPLE, OPFFICIALS OR WHO EVER IS PULLLING THIS ARE HATERS SERIOUSLY.

Robin Laird IS THE BEST VAULT JUMPER IN THE SG VALLEY AND IN SOUTH PASADENA HIGH SCHOOL HISTORY PERIOD.

Anonymous said:

Ms. Laird has benefitted more from this so-called controversy, than she would have if she had won.

National Coverage of this has definitely put her in the spotlight for Colleges and Coaches.

I wouldn't be surprised if she already has offers.

tcchamps said:

I heard that they all shook hands and exchanged friendship bracelets at their meeting.

New York said:

Which coach was in question of getting disciplined? Hernandez for not checking each of his athletes, even after the frosh sprinters had been warned??? Why would Knowles be disciplined for pointing this out? If the ruling is controversial, then maybe the judge/rules committee should be disciplined.

anonymous said:

featherhead! Move on dude. I knew this was a NON-STORY!!! It looks like south pas coaches backtracked to cover themselves. People should wait for FACTS before making judgements...

featherhead said:

Guilty in the highest of all courts- that of public opinion

Leave a comment

About this blog

Miguel Melendez

Miguel Melendez is the Preps Editor at the Pasadena Star-News.

Melendez worked as a correspondent for the San Gabriel Valley Tribune for three years and later landed a job as a freelance writer at the Los Angeles Times before accepting an offer at The Orange County Register covering high schools.

Melendez covered Major League Soccer at The Register for three years before being promoted to report on the Lakers, Angels and Dodgers for the Web. Melendez also worked for the Daytona Beach News-Journal, Fresno Bee, Oakland Tribune and The Boston Globe.

E-mail opinions, suggestions and tips to miguel.melendez@sgvn.com.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Miguel Melendez published on May 14, 2010 11:18 AM.

Baseball: Arcadia goes for perfection tonight at CV was the previous entry in this blog.

BREAKING NEWS: Arcadia finishes perfect 14-0!!!!! is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Recent Comments

Link Building on UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident : High quality info here! Keep up the great work. I love the feelings be ...

swiss gear laptop backpack on UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident : I am not in truth positive if top tactics have emerged around stuff si ...

Link Building on UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident : High quality info here! Keep up the great work. I love the feelings be ...

Collections on UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident : Wow, amazing blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you mak ...

Seo Las Vegas on UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident : Kudos to you! This is a really good blog here and I love your style of ...

Get Backlinks on UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident : Dreamin. I love blogging. You all express your feelings the right way, ...

Forum on UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident : Interesting thoughts here. I appreciate you taking the time to share t ...

Singapore Business Directory Freelancer Listings Classifieds on UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident : I love the way you write and also the theme on your blog. Did you code ...

Web Designer Phoenix on UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident : Keep focusing on your blog. I love how we can all express our feelings ...

lavoro a domicilio on UPDATE: Coach won't be disciplined for track incident : Uhm... I don't really know what to think... but I have a question I'd ...

Powered by Movable Type 4.25

Advertisement

Other blogs

Aram at Thursday's Bonita Passing Scrimmage ... in Best High School Sports Blog - Fred Robledo Talks Prep Sports
Failed jewelry store robbery reported in La Puente in Crime Scene
CIF champions from the WSGV in 2010-11 school year. in High School Sports Blog -- From The Sidelines with Miguel Melendez
New zipline tour opening in Wrightwood in Tanks for the Memories
Whittingham looks like two-horse race in Inside Horse Racing