Eye of the Beholder
Funny thing about Brian De Palma movies. Even the bad ones, and "Black Dahlia" definitely is bad, are packed with different pleasures for different people.
I could not agree less with my colleague Glenn Whipp about Fiona Shaw's two scenes. I laughed at bit at her dinner table twitchathlon while thinking all the while that a little self-control would have made that performance much funnier. And her spasmodic final scene (that we don't want to give too much away about) was, to my sensibilities, just awful. It turned an already unwieldy suite of over-explanation into a ludicrous freak show and made a terrible ending more insufferable.
But if Glenn and others liked her work, it's perfectly fine with me. That's just the way things go with De Palma movies.
I enjoyed about half a dozen of the director's specialty set-pieces in the movie. The long track through the wartime zuit suit riots which the cops find so amusing. The brutal boxing match staged and cut in a subjective yet visceral way that we haven't seen in hundreds of other fight sequences. How we're perversely distracted from the discovery of the Dahlia's body, which any other filmmaker would have made the biggest and most obvious sequence. The gorgeous manipulation of space, rhythm and atmosphere during a Hitchcockian multiple murder. K. d. lang singing through a big, bent Busby Berekelyesque production number at a lesbian nightclub . . .
And then there's "Black Dahlia's" one genuinely good performance, Mia Kirshner's as Elizabeth Short, the dead woman herself, seen in a series of flashbacks trying to land a movie role. Ironically, she's the only character in the film who truly comes alive. That's probably because Kirshner's scenes were original and improvised, and not burdened by novelist James Ellroy's fun-to-read but essentially unpeakable prose. It may also have something to do with the fact that these bits are actually little movies-within-the-movie about the process of moviemaking, and De Palma directed them best because that's his greatest passion.
None of which makes "Black Dahlia's" other characters or its overall story convincing or engaging. But like many a De Palma film that was widely reviled upon its release - "Dressed to Kill," "Scarface," "Body Double," "Femme Fatale" - "Dahlia" may just earn some redemption as the years go by. As can already be seen, what some see as major flaws others are finding enjoyable.
Sneaky freak, that Brian.
207 Comments
Leave a comment
About this blog
Bob Strauss writes about entertainment for the Los Angeles Daily News.
This is a great Blog!
If you are suffering from many physical problems like diabetes
If you are suffering from many physical problems like diabetes
mpygtis kwbqe onhlak bjxsk soydxfz biao whdvyc
gvzbuanpt nhxlibzoy hukzolexa grjfmo bayngqk jzvfdaq sfkdlvhnc http://www.djth.fgsd.com
Cool site. Thank you.
http://www.uwyo.edu/bike/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=390 buy xanax
Cool site. Thank you.
http://www.uwyo.edu/bike/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=390 buy xanax
Very good site. Thank you!
http://chinesefreewebs.com/wihrol/chesty_morgan.html Chesty morgan
Very good site. Thank you!
http://chinesefreewebs.com/wihrol/chesty_morgan.html Chesty morgan
xanax buy alprazolam online
http://dooneyandburkepurse.vdforum.ru/ "> dooney and burke purse
http://dooneyandburkepurse.vdforum.ru/ "> dooney and burke purse
http://dooneyandburkepurse.vdforum.ru/ "> dooney and burke purse
I like your site. Well done!
I'll come by again soon.
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@durgs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
Wow! This is gonna be a good season!
Take care
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
Nice site. Thank you!!!
http://www.volny.cz/heskey777/tramadol/ buy cheap tramadol
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
Cool site. Thanks.
http://www.volny.cz/heskey777/hydrocodone/ hydrocodone ibuprofen
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
Hmmm...That's kind of strange...
But it was interesting.
Thanks.
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
Cool site. Thank you.
http://www.volny.cz/heskey777/ringtone/ mp3 to ringtone
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
herbals@drugs.com
Good site. Thank you!
http://sites.blockstar.com/micks/air-ticket.html air flight tickets
Nice site. Thank you!
http://sites.blockstar.com/micks/tramadol.html order tramadol online
Cool site. Thanks:-)
http://sites.blockstar.com/micks/vicodin.html vicodin detox
Good site. Thanks!
http://sites.blockstar.com/micks/valium.html diazepam 2mg
porn dvds
Cool site. Thanks:-)
http://rlink.org/5378 unemployment insurance
pyyhcf [url=http://nmzaiswc.com]test2[/url]
Hello! Good Site! Thanks you! pdokpgyfdaz
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Thanks for this site!
[url=http://www.megalan.bg/content/buy_tramadol.html]buy tramadol[/url]
Good site. Thank you!!!
http://tadalafil2.12gbfree.com tadalafil
Cool site. Thanks.
http://lemonlaw.12gbfree.com lemon law
Very good site. Thanks:-)
http://web-cam-2.12gbfree.com web cam sex
Hey This is pretty cool. I think it's a decent blog.
You all have fun now!
Very good site. Thanks!
http://sprintringtone.12gbfree.com sprint ringtone
Hey This is pretty cool. I think it's a decent blog.
Thanks a lot and have fun!
Good site. Thank you.
http://ringtone.12gbfree.com tracfone ringtone
Cool site. Thank you.
http://personalloan.12gbfree.com unsecured personal loan
Hey This is pretty cool. I think it's a decent blog.
Thanks a lot and have fun!
gediszcb
Cool site. Thank you:-)
http://cashaploan.12gbfree.com cash advance payday loan
Hey Your site is a little "different" but not bad.
I've seen a lot worse. Good content but try spicing it up a bit.
Thanks and good luck!
Cool site. Thank you:-)
http://priceline-ticket.12gbfree.com priceline airline ticket
Cool site. Thank you!
http://flight-ch.12gbfree.com cheap flight
Good site. Thanks:-)
http://airfare.12gbfree.com cheap airfare
Nice site. Thank you:-)
http://soundf.12gbfree.com sound forge
Good site. Thank you!!!
http://madcowdis.12gbfree.com mad cow disease
Very good site. Thanks.
pedomov.12gbfree.com free pedo porn movie
Very good site. Thank you!
http://www.datingfunda.com/userspic/admin/functions/levitra.htm levitra pills
Very good site. Thank you!
http://www.datingfunda.com/userspic/admin/functions/levitra.htm levitra pills
Pretty Nice Site.
Keep up the good work...
Very good site. Thanks!!!
http://cshot.111mb.net/index.html cum shot
Cool site. Thanks.
http://www.datingfunda.com/userspic/admin/functions/ringtone3.htm metallica ringtone
Nice site. Thank you!!!
http://www.datingfunda.com/userspic/admin/functions/ringtone6.htm elvis presley ringtone
Nice site. Thank you!!!
http://www.datingfunda.com/userspic/admin/functions/ringtone6.htm elvis presley ringtone
Cool site. Thank you!!!
http://www.forumsdot.com/teamer/functions/phentermine_adipex.htm adipex com
Good site. Thank you:-)
http://www.hiphopschool.com/triplexfm/functions/credit_cards1.htm shell credit card
Nice site. Thanks:-)
http://www.horos.ru/forum/templates/subSilver/images/lang_english/functions/credit_cards2.htm instant approval credit card
Nice site. Thanks!
http://www.horos.ru/forum/templates/subSilver/images/lang_english/functions/hydrocodone_vicodine.htm hydrocodone 5 500
Very good site. Thank you:-)
http://www.ultraslan.org/ultraslanforum/images/functions/hydrocodone_vicodine.htm codeine syrup
Nice site. Thanks.
http://www.ultraslan.org/ultraslanforum/images/functions/hydrocodone.htm cheap hydrocodone
Very good site. Thanks!
http://www.ultraslan.org/ultraslanforum/images/functions/tramadol.htm cheap ultram
Very good site. Thank you!
http://www.positivos.com/tmp/functions/ringtone6.htm free real music ringtone sprint
Good site. Thank you.
http://www.angel-owners.de/functions/credit_cards4.htm fake credit card
Cool site. Thanks!!!
http://www.angel-owners.de/functions/insurance1.htm car insurance quotes
Cool site. Thank you:-)
http://www.angel-owners.de/functions/ultram.htm drug ultram
Very good site. Thanks:-)
http://www.computermail.nl/forum/templates/subSilver/images/lang_english/functions/credit_cards1.htm credit card processing
Cool site. Thank you!!!
http://www.computermail.nl/forum/templates/subSilver/images/lang_english/functions/insurance2.htm acceptance insurance
Cool site. Thank you!!!
http://www.computermail.nl/forum/templates/subSilver/images/lang_english/functions/insurance2.htm acceptance insurance
Nice site. Thanks!!!
http://www.computermail.nl/forum/templates/subSilver/images/lang_english/functions/ringtone2.htm ringtones for lg
Nice site. Thank you!!!
http://www.computermail.nl/forum/templates/subSilver/images/lang_english/functions/vicodin.htm generic vicodin
Very good site. Thank you!!!
http://boarder-forum.powder4you.com/functions/credit_cards4.htm apply for credit cards
Nice site. Thanks!!!
http://geomapnw.ess.washington.edu/newsletter/themes/shared/js/xinha/functions/xanax_alprazolam.htm alprazolam xr
Jenna
Hi people! I wanted to get a credit card to combine the two I have now so I would have only one bill. Well I applied at but they only gave me a credit line of 2000. And I needed 5000 to pay off the credit cards I have at present. What do I do now? Please help.
http://577ards.info >500 dollar limit unsecured credit card
Guys, please help. I urge for a credit card and need to apply very soon as I have a HUGE debt! This is my best chance! Please advice if I can rely on this?
http://559-caard.info >orchard bank gold mastercard or orchard bank platinum
There are so many tricks the bank use to make their reward programs sound enticing. But usually it's not that easy to get a cash back bonus. Some of them want you to make your purchases at particular places. Or sometimes you have to spend a certain amount of money. Before applying for a credit card scrutinize the details at
http://astablish-cadr.info >credit card with 597 fico
I Hi there! I'm in search for credit cards with airline miles. There are several offers at three websites. But I chose one site about credit. Is a reliable, please, tell me? Go to
http://beggineracrd.info >mbna 529
Hi, I'm having now 8 credit cards but all they are from local banks. I need online credit application service. Where can I get it? So far I was at a website, but can you ensure it's worth applying there? Please see and tell me, thanks. It was
http://beginers-ard.info >approval for credit card with credit score of 550
Hi, I'm having now 8 credit cards but all they are from local banks. I need online credit application service. Where can I get it? So far I was at a website, but can you ensure it's worth applying there? Please see and tell me, thanks. It was
http://beginers-ard.info >approval for credit card with credit score of 550
Three phrases should be among the most common in our daily usage. They are: Thank you, I am grateful and I appreciate.
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Hi, everybody. I am going to get married but my boyfriend and I are still running credit card debt we made when at college yet. They say that we'd better improve our credit ratings if we want to apply for a loan to celebrate the wedding. So, now we both are looking for bad or fair credit card applications to repair our scores. We wonder if
http://applicationcom-orchard-credit-bank.cleaningup-cdedit.info >credits cards like orchard credit card
Cool site. Thanks!
http://forum.jerusalemsummit.org/templates/subSilver/images/lang_english/functions/meridia_Sibutramine.htm meridia diet
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Cool site. Thank you!
http://talkingtechs.com/functions/ultram.htm is ultram addictive
Cool site. Thank you!
http://talkingtechs.com/functions/ultram.htm is ultram addictive
Nice site. Thanks:-)
http://www.aprox.de/functions/insurance1.htm health insurance
Very good site. Thank you:-)
http://www.southern-stitches.com/functions/insurance3.htm insurance health plan
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Very nice point of view! Respect!
Nice site. Thank you!!!
http://foros.latingames.com/templates/subSilver/images/lang_english/functions/ringtone1.htm free ringtone
Nice site. Thank you!!!
http://foros.latingames.com/templates/subSilver/images/lang_english/functions/ringtone1.htm free ringtone
HIV positive people may, may not work in health organizations
meu site... queria que avaliassem e dessem opinioes!
My life's been pretty dull these days. Not much on my mind recently. My mind is like a fog, but shrug. I haven't been up to anything today, but oh well. I haven't gotten much done lately.
There are too many, not enough handicapped parking spaces in our city
I feel like a fog, not that it matters. I've pretty much been doing nothing , but eh. Today was a loss. I haven't gotten much done for a while.
More or less nothing seems important. I've just been letting everything happen without me recently. I can't be bothered with anything recently, but such is life. My life's been generally bland today. Not much on my mind these days, but eh.