Some more thoughts on the San Bernardino police investigation

| | Comments (2) |

Most of you probably already saw today's (CLICK LINK HERE>) story about an unfinished investigation into a serious police/community clash in August 2007.

There is another, shorter story on this same topic in the (CLICK LINK HERE>)Press Enterprise.

Let's recap the high points of the story:

* On Aug. 19, police respond for unknown reasons to the Dorjils apartment complex. A crowd is gathered for a curbside vigil for a man slain the day before. A violent clash between police and the crowd ensues.

* The crowd was nearly completely African American.

* There are an unknown number of arrests and injuries.

* The next day, Aug. 20, dozens of residents of the high-crime apartments come to a City Council meeting and recite shocking details of alleged police misconduct.

* After the meeting adjourns, Mayor Pat Morris takes it upon himself to console the grieving mother of the man whose vigil was the setting of the clash. He drapes his arm around her and vows a "thorough investigation."

* At the time, some police were a bit miffed at the mayor's conduct, thinking he was coming dangerously close to suggesting they were wrong, instead of an allegedly violent street gathering.

* Also that night, Chief Michael Billdt pledges that the department will conduct an internal investigation into its conduct.

* Days later, Councilman Rikke Van Johnson demands an independent probe as well as the 9-1-1 tapes from the incident. Whispers grow at the time that there are no 9-1-1 tapes because police allegedly sprung on the protesters without a distress call.

* Billdt decides not to release the tapes, saying it is part of an investigation. City Attorney James F. Penman makes clear that state law gives BIlldt the discretion to release the tapes if he wishes. What the 9-1-1 tapes contain, or even whether they exist, remain unknown.

* A U.S. Justice Department official is drawn to town. She remarks that relations are clearly strained and hosts a number of meetings that include the community, the chief, the mayor and others.

* The issue fades from the public's attention.

* One year later, police admit their investigation is unfinished.

* The police officers Bill of Rights suggests that once one year has elapsed, no internal discipline can be levied on officers, possibly rendering the investigation's outcome moot.

* When pressed, Lt. Scott Paterson says community non-cooperation is at least partly to blame for the protracted investigation. Paterson notes the positive community/police meetings on the West side under the watchful eye of the federal mediator. He says sensitivity training for officers has been a success.

* When asked whether he has fulfilled his promise to the man's mother for a "thorough investigation," Morris gives a lengthy response without answering that specific question. Morris does, however, place blame on the community, again for alleged non-cooperation with police investigators. Morris also notes that even the federal official had little luck getting cooperation from residents. Morris also points out how well the police chief and other top officials responded to the federal mediator and the community meetings on the West side.

* Community member Linda Hart says police and the mayor are wrong to blame residents for their own inexcusably protracted investigation. She calls for an independent probe.


This is an important story for a number of reasons. What is most important isn't even whether police acted properly or improperly. It's the perception.
This community, for which the police theoretically work, has little faith in its public servants. When serious allegations of wrongdoing arise, department leaders know that maintaining the public trust comes from full, open, and swift investigations that people believe in.

This is not a neighborhood of middle-class people. There are criminals in the Dorjils and Lt. Zion Manor for sure. But there are plenty of decent people and children. Virtually everyone is poor. Almost everyone is black.

Dozens of these very residents came to City Hall en masse and were promised an investigation. One year later the investigation is incomplete and the statute of limitations appears to have expired, and police leaders and the mayor took zero percent of the responsibility. They did, however, say the community was at least partly to blame.

2 Comments

rararoadrunner said:

The good news was that Robert Rogers wrote this piece: definitely a light of truth cutting through the smog of disinformation sold by "mainstream media."

Bad news is that Mr. Rogers is no longer with The Sun, having, for whatever reason, decided to move on.

No matter! Other voices will get the word out about our "City of the Future" (crisis), helping us to navigate through the coming "years lit with lightning"...

Linda Hart said:

We have not been given any report it is now 2008
sorry to hear Robert has left he was a real reporter"

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

About SB Now Blog

Andrew Edwards. E-mail Andrew here.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Robert Rogers published on August 27, 2008 10:15 AM.

Investigation into police/residents clash still ongoing was the previous entry in this blog.

Police union speaks, says Phoenix probe sunk by politics is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Breaking News

Other blogs

Advertisement

Powered by Movable Type 4.25