Italy 3 U.S. 1
After taking a shock lead against the world champions via a Landon Donovan PK despite being reduced to 10 men after a half hour when Ricardo Clark was sent off for a late tackle, was it too much to expect the U.S. to hold on for its first-ever win over Italy.
It is when Clint Dempsey insists upon giving away the ball (again) in his own half.