Save the hype for bigger marks

| | Comments (0) |

57 Saves.jpgDoes it seem as if Francisco Rodriguez's saves-record pursuit is getting less attention than other record chases? I sure hope so.

Rodriguez's next save for the Angels will be his 58th of the season, breaking the record held by Bobby Thigpen of the Chicago White Sox. The question isn't how Rodriguez's achievement stacks up with Thigpen's, it's whether any achievement involving the statistic called saves is as big a deal as the feats of starting pitchers and hitters.

My attitude, and this applied to Eric Gagne's record-setting saves streak for the Dodgers a few years ago, is that the feats of bullpen closers are more like curiosities than Cooperstown calling cards.

- This record matters less than others because relatively speaking, having a dedicated closer is such a relatively recent innovation that these bullpen aces' accomplishments are hard to compare to pitchers' of the past. Eleven pitchers have had 50 or more saves in a season, all since 1990. How many pitchers of the earlier 1900s could have been great closers if the job had existed?

- This record is devalued because the role of saves-getter is an appointed job and his success depends too much on what his teammates do for three hours before he joins the game. A starting pitcher can earn as many wins, as low an ERA as he's capable, and a hitter can roll up as many home runs, as many stolen bases as his ability allows. But a relief pitcher can pile up saves only if the manager points to him in spring training and says, "You get all the saves this season," in the process telling the rest of the bullpen, "You get none of the saves."

- Meaning this record reflects a player's actual performance less than most baseball records do. In fact, judging by Rodriguez's ERA (2.42) so far, this is a worse-than-average season for him, and going by his hits-to-innings and walks-to-strikeouts ratios, this is his worst season. Compare K-Rod's season to the others on the all-time saves list, and his ERA is only seventh best, his hits-to-innings ratio is only sixth best, and his walks-to-strikeouts ratio is worse than all except ... Thigpen's.

Look, I'm not knocking Rodriguez (though I can do without his me-first victory celebrations). He's a great talent, and he's doing what the Angels ask of him.

Nor am I forgetting that records don't have to be indicators of greatness. They're just records, inviting interpretation.

I'm just saying that if it seems like sports journalists are treating Frankie Rodriguez's soon-to-be saves record as if it belongs on the back pages of the record book, that's because it does.

Leave a comment

About this blog

Kevin Modesti watches sports from a new angle since his promotion from sports columnist to sports editor for the Los Angeles Newspaper Group. In his new blog, Modesti not only comments on the big sports stories of the moment-- he talks about what makes them big. Think of it as a conversation with readers about how these stories should be covered.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Kevin Modesti published on September 12, 2008 3:42 PM.

A question for football fans was the previous entry in this blog.

How should a winner act? is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Recent Comments

Powered by Movable Type 4.25

Advertisement

Other blogs

Girls' basketball: Sierra Canyon comes back to beat Carson in Daily News High School Spotlight
USC No. 1 in Inside USC with Scott Wolf
Weekly Q&A in Inside UCLA with Jon Gold
Will Kobe kick butts? in Inside the Lakers
Play it forward: Dec. 27-Jan. 2 on your sports calendar in Farther Off the Wall