More from today’s column with Sal Paolantonio, on “How Football Explains America” (linked here):
Q: In this time of a financial crisis, can football explain how we’re headed into a recession, when it most often appears to all who watch the game that college and pro football seem to be recession-proof?
A: “I’m not sure they are recession proof. Let’s look at what’s happening with the new NFL stadiums being built in Dallas (pictured above) and New York. The Giants, Jets and Cowboys are having a very difficult time selling exorbitantly priced so-called Personal Seat Licenses. They are charging tens of thousands of dollars for the right to buy a ticket, and they are asking those who in the past did not pay those fees to pony up. For months, there has been stiff resistance on principle. Now, longtime fans can’t afford it or simply cannot borrow the money to pay for a $50,000 seat license.”
Q: The NFL, in particular, seems to stifle the freedom of expression – some call it the No Fun League — which is an essential element of being America. Do you find that counterproductive?
A: “I think Commissioner Roger Goodell is ahead of the curve by enforcing decorum in the game. You don’t want to slide into WWE mode. It’s a game with time-honored traditions, and those help sell the game. So, the league is trying to protect its brand, and thus its investment. Can’t fault them for that. Same goes with Mr. Goodell’s insistence on protecting player safety. The players should be protected. It’s their livelihood and the owners’ investment. But it is tackle football. That is the essence of the game. That should not be diluted.”
That’s the title of the book published recently (Triumph Books, 211 pages, $24.95), authored by Sal Paolantonio in a very thought-provoking manner that fits the pieces of football’s evolution on both the college and pro scale to how the country came together and continues to press upon its ideals forward.
Mark Bowden, author of the new book, “The Best Game Ever: Giants vs. Colts, 1958, and the Birth of the Modern NFL,” probably offers his explanation of Paolantonio’s book on the jacket cover: “So it turns out that Sal Paolantonio doesn’t just talk about football on television, but he really thinks about it! His book is a breezy, conceptual tour through the history of America and of football, showing they are, in fact, one and the same. From war to jazz, from racism to integration, from immigrant waves of Scotch-Irish to Tonga islanders, from dioramas in the display windows of newspapers to ‘Monday Night Football,’ from Jim Thorpe to Eli Manning, the story of the game mirrors the story of our country. Who knew? All those lazy Sunday afternoons on the couch were really anthropological research.”
Paolantonio says he got the idea for this book after reading Michael MacCambridge’s “America’s Game: The Epic Story of How Pro Football Captured a National” and realizing that as good as the book was, it never really explained the “How” in the title. He also notes the Franklin Foer best-seller, “How Soccer Explains The World,” and found a template for the way he could explain football’s impact on America.
We caught up with SalPal for an on-line Q-and-A during his ESPN assignments, asking him to draw some comparisons to today’s United States and the sport. An excerpt:
Q: What does Thanksgiving, the true American holiday, mean to football and visa versa, with examples you’ve used in the book as well as others you may think of this time of year, maybe of giving thanks for health and family and duty to country?
A: Well, the marriage of Thanksgiving and football started purely as a commercial idea — a way to sell tickets to games and advertising in Chicago newspapers. And like most everything else in this country, it has become mythologized. (See Christmas. Macy’s basically created the idea of shopping and giving on a grand scale on Christmas — commercializing it.) But what I like about Thanksgiving is how it helps explain America through football. With local Turkey Bowl games all over the country, Americans have taken ownership of the tradition. We’ve democratized it, just like Fantasy Football has democratized the NFL. Used to be that you would bet on a team put together by somebody else — a coach or general manager. Now, you invest financially and emotionally on teams you have assembled in your fantasy leagues (and I do mean plural). People of have taken ownership of the mythology. That is how football explains us as a people.
A link (here) to the history of Amos Alonzo Stagg helping to form the Chicago-Michigan game back in the late 1890s.
If we had done a “normal” media column this week, maybe some of this would have made it in. Probably not:
== Oh, to be Bob Papa.
Thursday, he did the play-by-play on the Thanksgiving Day broadcast of Arizona-Philadelphia for the NFL Network.
Saturday, he’s doing play-by-play on the Grambling-Southern college football game for NBC from New Orleans.
Then, he somehow has to get to Ontario (not Canada, but that outpost near Riverside) by 7 p.m. local time Saturday for HBO’s broadcast (with Max Kellerman) for the a “Boxing After Dark” telecast (airing at 10 p.m., delayed in the West) between Paul Williams-Verno Phillips and Chris Arreola-Travis Walker from the new Citizens Business Bank Arena.
Sunday, he’s going back across the country to do the New York Giants (he’s their radio play-by-play man) as they are in Washington D.C. with a 1 p.m. local kickoff.
Oh, wait. We knew it was too nuts to be true.
NBC was incorrect when it issued a press release Wednesday saying that Papa would be doing the football game Saturday. Tom Hammond is calling that game instead. Papa confirmed as much with an email on Wednesday as well.
“Yes, this entire week has been crazy for me starting this past Sunday in Arizona with the Giants,” Papa said from his Blacberry. “Plus throwing in my Giants TV shows and my Sirius NFL radio show each morning has made this a challenging week.”
== CBS will bring Victoria’s Secret model Selita Ebanks to “join the guys live on the set to help them with their NFL picks” Sunday, according a netowk release.
Oh, right. Because CBS is carrying the annual V.S. Fashion Show on Wednesday at 10 p.m. (linked here). You know Fox would cross promote it as well if it had the opportunity.
This also means it could be the first time all season you’ve seen the CBS NFL pregame show. It has JB. And the good Boomer. And another old quarterback. And a loquacious former NFL tight end. And a recently retired coach. And still, a cartoon guy named Thurston Long … he’s not there?
Something like that.
== The Associated Press reported Monday that the NFL “quietly changed its policy this season” to allow more viewers to see games on the NFL Network. It affects only a small number of viewers in outlying areas of the cities of the teams who are in the game. Those games were always simulcast by the NFL Network on a local, over-the-air channel to an area that the NFL decided was the “home market.” The games, however, were blacked out last season on cable systems that carried that local station outside the home market. Now those systems’ subscribers will be able to watch. Those who don’t get the local channel on their cable system, however, still won’t see the games unless they receive NFL Network.
“It made more sense to us upon reflection that if a cable station was carrying the programing 24-7 that it be allowed to carry our NFL Network games,” NFL executive vice president Joe Browne said.
Thursday’s Eagles-Cardinals game on the NFL Network was simulcast on WPVI in Philadelphia; viewers in Harrisburg, York, Scranton and Wilkes-Barre who already got the station on cable were also able to see it on that channel. But the Phoenix station airing the game isn’t on any cable systems outside the home market, so no additional fans will had access.
== Yup, NBC is already promoting its coverage of the 2010 Winter Olympics from Vancouver. The first ads ran during the network’s telecast of the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day parade and during the National Dog Show on Thursday. “This isn’t a start of the campaign so much as a nod to the success of Beijing and a way to introduce Vancouver as a unique setting and one of the most beautiful places in North America,” said Mike McCarley, the NBC VP of strategic marketing, told the Sports Business Daily.
==ESPNU has the NCAA Women’s Volleyball Championship Selection Show on Sunday at 7 p.m., hosted by Beth Mowins with analyst Karch Kiraly. The ESPN network’s coverage of the event starts Dec. 13 with all four Regional Finals live on ESPNU. The title match is Saturday, Dec. 20 at 5 p.m. on ESPN2.
AND THE CLOSING ARGUMENT:
== Have we got caught up on the Kenny Mayne “Mayne Street” series?
They do evoke a laugh or two, or three, and may really be setting the template for future endeavors on the Internet for the ADD way of viewing a series that otherwise would be fighting for time and sponsorship on a major network.
Catching you up:
Here’s episode 5, and wait for that classic line: “Kenny, where are your pants?”
And episode 4, “Kenny The Clown” with “sorry, my arm is stuck”:
And episode 3, “Poker,” with Neil Everett, wearing a viser and ear piece, and Chris McKendry as the fourth wheel:
After each episode, stick around for the outtakes.
We’ve already delivered the first two episodes. More to come….
Adding to today’s column of the Dubious Dozen of the Sports Media for 2008 (linked here), we offer these leftovers, some of which, we have no follow-up news to deliver:
The culprit: Danyelle Sargent and Mike Francessa The crime: Sent by Fox to be a sideline reporter at asked to interview new 49ers head coach Mike Singletary, Sargent bungled a question so badly that it had to be stopped and re-asked. The problem is, the video of that first question, when she asked Singletary if he called the late Bill Walsh upon being hired, was captured on a satellite feed and broadcast on a New York TV show hosted by Francessa, and repeated across the Internet, as well as the Versus show “Sports Soup.”
==A clip of the Francessa clip of Sargent (linked here) The aftermath: Fox said it would file a protest with the NFL for unauthorized use of the video. Sargent, who once dropped the “F” word during a open mike when she worked on ESPNEWS two years ago, has not been on the Fox NFL telecast since that October day.
After a day when the Internet gave her a migraine and she “stayed in bed for like five hours,” Sargent explained how she asked new Singletary about a phone call to Walsh, who died in July 2007.
On Dan Patrick’s syndicated radio show, Sargent said: “I misspoke. What I meant to say is, ‘I heard he was one of the first phone calls that you made when you decided that you wanted to get into coaching.’ . . . I didn’t even realize that I misspoke, and then the producer at the game in my ear says, ‘Wait, stop.’
“I don’t see how anyone could have thought that it was on air because I stopped in the middle of the interview. There was no toss-back. I stopped in the middle of the interview and started talking to my producer. And I’ve never seen anyone do that during a game.”
Said NFL senior VP of media operations Howard Katz: “To use an outtake was unfair. If it had been on the broadcast, it would have been fair game.”
“Obviously a mistake was made,” Francesa told the New York Times. “If we’d known that, we wouldn’t have used it.”
The culprit: ESPN The crime: In November, an advertisement pitch that was supposedly made to the all-sports network was released to the blog AwfulAnnouncing.com (linked here), and later reported on in USA Today. Anomaly, a New York ad agency, planned an ad campaign for ESPN specifying what it wanted actors to do in portraying students from different colleges who were working in “the ESPN College Basketball Call Center (CBBCC),” people on the phone “to get them to watch more College Basketball. Basically they are selling college basketball.”
But what type of stereotypes did they need to exploit?
The memo said that, for example, a Tennessee co-ed needed to be “slutty” and “crazy.” The “defining characteristic” of the Marquette student is “you don’t really remember her.” Syracuse would need a “Jewish kid” who loves college — “all-you-can-eat buffets in the cafeteria, who knew?” A student from “Perdue” needed to look 14. The aftermath: ESPN canceled the campaign.
“Our marketing department just learned of this casting call today,” said ESPN’s Mike Soltys. “The language and approach reflected in that document were not approved by us and in no way represent ESPN or the respect we have for the college community.”