Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied

| | Comments (45) |

With soccer semifinals today, we thought we would push the Baseball Preview back to Thursday instead of Wednesday. This gives soccer the stage in tomorrow's paper, and baseball the stage on Thursday, since there are no games on Wednesday. Also, while I've been working on the preview I learned today that highly regarded junior pitcher Jacob Shirley, who transferred to South Hills from West Covina, has been ruled ineligible by CIF, citing "Undue Influence."

Nothing gets me ready for the baseball season like "Centerfield"


45 Comments

Wow!, this was a real quality post. In theory I'd like to write like this too - taking time and real effort to make a good article... but what can I say... I procrastinate a lot and never seem to get something done

This is my first time I have visited here. I found a lot of interesting information in your blog. From the volume of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one! keep up the great work.

Sweet - happy new year!

Jack Michaels said:

Judy North...you want athletes to come to your school, but you won't let any leave. And if they try, you do something sneaky to make sure they aren't eligible. Isn't that true?

Message to Jake Shirley... said:

Make an appeal to CIF State. Hey if that b-baller at Workman CJ Guerrero made it happen you can too.

U at least gotta try!

If it chonks up then the next word you'll hear from me (I'll say it in advance) is "it's a sign of the times".

-A Jake Shirley Supporter

right said:

its not up to WC for him to be ok to play its covina unified that does all the investagating....

Get the story right said:

I know cause I've been informed by different coaches on what happened with this situation, and also because with the past transfers who were lost that I know of, WC didn't make an issue of it.

2009 said:

Get the story right--unless you're an administrator at WC how do you know they would have let it go like all the other transfers. Doubt it. It's chicken sh@t that WC and CIF are making such a big a big deal. I'm with Fred on just let the kids play.

Get the story right said:

McCuff, nice little spin job, your twisting this thing a 180 degree's backwards, sure Jacob is a good kid, he's a great kid and I wish him well, but tell me exactly who was giving him a hard time at WC? The only reason WC protested is because of the
reason that cif was given
for the transfer.
The reason given was that Shirley was being harrassed, when in truth he wasn't being harrassed at all. This made West Covina students/teammates look bad and it made the school look like they were letting this happen to Shirley which wasn't true, the coaches wouldn't let that happen. This is the only reason WC would cite undue influence. If they hadn't given that false excuse about the hardship WC would have let this go like they have let other
transfers go. When called on it the person giving cif the excuse admitted to WC that it was just an excuse so they could get the transfer.
So Fred try not to side so quickly with South Hills
on this matter.
To the person who said WC won't be as good as last season, I disagree. West Covina should be much better this coming season, the kids are working hard in the offseason and will be ready for your Huskies.

Huskies said:

right,

Good Luck!

bearcat14 said:

bonita will be unstoppable this year. damien is garbage and carries no identity

right said:

to the guy who goes by huskies, thats funny how you say we have no QB and that we have no defence and that your team could be better this year, dude you starting to sound like FRED. your team is done your team had alot of seniors and did you forget that our JV team beat your JV team what 49 to 6. your getting no transfers your future QB left and you have no running game. heck your starting running wouldent even start over at west covina. get over it South Hills is great for the TRIBUNE ONLY. so you guys have 2 tuff games next year and you loose both of them and the TRIBUNE will still give your team a lot of love. If South Hills would have bet West Covina last year the TRIBUNE would have put in the front page the kings of Cameron but you LOST and all they did was put a small article. talk all you want will see next year.....

VOR said:

Low blow McCuff. So low, that I am not even going to quote you. You can't single people out who have no control over a situation. If you want to talk about falling apart mention the many poor decision makers in this kids life who gerrymandered and campaigned to try to fly a kid, who is big as a blimp in this area, under the radar and across town. Who really lost? The kid and all who love to see a great hurler.

Huskies said:

right,

No fool just letting you know whats going to happen... WC next year will not be better than the WC team this year... SH this coming year could potentially be even better overall than they were this year... WC has no QB and no Defense, it's hard to win games like that... GOOD LUCK!

jcaz, quotes from airplane the movie ! said:

The fogs getting thicker, and Leon’s getting larger!

You have clearance Clarence, Roger, Roger. Whats our vector Victor?

Jacob Shirly wants to play for South Hills?

Shirly that cant be true?

Oh, and BTW, please dont call me shirly.

right said:

shirly didnt want to leave WC he had to leave because of his dad, from what i hear his dad was a pain in the butt. nobody was mad at him because of football all of his buddys are still from WC. when WC played South Hills in football Shirly was on the WC side with his freinds. and for the foool that said South Hill is going to beat WC in football this coming season you got another thing coming WC is going to kill them dogs....

u can use my address said:

why is it that everyone thinks it's only south hills who recruits -- all schools, yes, all high schools have permit kids, "live with" kids or kids with downright phony addresses -- big freakin deal, it should only be a problem when they start to school hop every year.

WOW said:

Just move? HA. Why not just lie and give a Covina address like all the other kids do? Man, talk about investigative reporting...there should be a story on how many kids are being recruited into South Hills and do not live in Covina. I personally know of at least 3 in the past 5 years. Doesn't sound like much, but how many are there? Would be cool to find out.

From what I've heard the football teams (WC vs. SH) have played some pretty good games recently. I wonder how that would go if WC had WC players, and SH had Covina products...nah, we like good games too. Please South Hills, don't stop recruiting, then you'd be as unwatchable as the Colts across town, and NOBODY wants that! HAHAHAH

Why said:

Tell it...

I use the word students because there are MANY good students that leave and go to Hollenbeck. See, because I do NOT see high school sports like professionals (get over yourself) I DO tell it like it is...These KIDS are students. Sucked into the recruiting and games playing of SMith, Bogan and the rest of the gang. Sure I know some of these "athletes" not be asked to take real classloads over there, but they are still technically STUDENTS afterall. Are you opening the can of worms that SOuth Hills doesn't view their kids as students first? WOW...maybe someone would like to know this fact.

I also think the fact that WC kids are left on waiting lists for other permit kids stinks. SO i feel for that post. And I also think if WC wants to fight for athletes, someone needs to stick up for the students too.

THESE KIDS ARE STUDENTS! THEY ARE NOT PROS. PARENTS NEED TO WAKE UP AND DECIDE WHAT'S BEST FOR THEIR KID. Do not listen to bloggers or coaches. You all know the stats, little Johny will not be playing sports in 5 years, so maybe STUDENT should stop being a bad word...

Just me.

Huskies said:

SH is going to tear up WC in baseball and football... We know that too!

Criminals and Crooks said:

South Hills recruits and West Covina sucks! Tell us something we don't know!

McCuff said:

It's absurd! Shirley is a good kid who was in a bad situatuion at WCHS because he did not want to play football any longer. Others made it tough for him to stay at the same school his brothers went too. His choice was WCHS as a freshmen, WCHS let him down by not protecting him when he stopped football. They did move and no one recruited him. They made a tough family decision at great personal expense to do what was best for Jacob. It's a shame that Loringer is so bitter that his program has fallen apart because of his own incompetence, that he has to take it out on young men with a future.

McCuff said:

It's absurd! Shirley is a good kid who was in a bad situatuion at WCHS because he did not want to play football any longer. Others made it tough for him to stay at the same school his brothers went too. His choice was WCHS as a freshmen, WCHS let him down by not protecting him when he stopped football. They did move and no one recruited him. They made a tough family decision at great personal expense to do what was best for Jacob. It's a shame that Loringer is so bitter that his program has fallen apart because of his own incompetence, that he has to take it out on young men with a future.

Living Legend said:

Hey Fredo (you actually remind me of Fredo Corleone, so i think that would make Bogan "michael corleone") let the kids play is that what you said. I can accept that if you would look into any of the un-due influence that goes on around your hero Bogans area of covina. Come on to say they are doing everything on the up and up is just turning a blind eye. I mean John Madden oops Judy North will do anything to get athletes in there, then as soon as the season is over and state testing starts in the spring she ships the kids on permit back to their home schools. Look into it Fredo..."I know it was you Fredo"

Fan said:

? is how many other kids at South Hills. Should be going to other schools. Look at Wells from last year football team.

?? said:

Shirley being denied--so does this mean he has to sit out just this year?
can he play football next season if he chooses to since he didn't play this year?

haha said:

"Rio will skip the High School season to head right for his Cooperstown induction"

That is funny and so very true.

wcshwcshwcshcharteroak said:

Jacob Shirley--just move--geeze you live 100 yards from the border of SH on the WC side--just move---give me a break West Covina--he lives closer to South Hills than West Covina and if a kid doen't want to go to your school why force him, so he can not thrive and drop out. No kid left behind, parents should be able to pick the school...

Tell it like it is said:

Why? Here's a question? Why are you saying "students" everyone (except lucy's mom)knows your talking about athletes...Cherry pick? Your students? Say what you mean! You're tired of South Hills stealing all of your athletes and then kicking your butts in the athletic arenas!!!!! "Students"! HA!

lucy mom said:

maybe if wc would stop letting in kids from all over the wc kids would want to go there--but kids are being brought in from everywhere--my daughter had to wait for an AP class because it was full--10 kids were permit kids--go figure? I buy a home in wc district , pay my taxes and my kids have to go on waiting lists? sorry. thats why she's at lucy's and why the wc kids don't want to go there.

why? said:

Why should WCHS continually allow their best students to go to South Hills? These kids are products of WEST COVINA schools, not Covina. West Covina should start fighting EVERY kid who wants to go to South Hills. Why do they always play second fiddle and allow South Hills to cherry-pick AND RECRUIT WC kids?

watch it will said:

Will Jones - Hold it right there buddy! The only team that will be bunting their way to any title this year is The Bishop Amat Lancers! AND DON'T YOU FORGET IT!!!!!

who said:

Who are Damiens Pitchers?

Will Jones said:

Inside info is that the Spartans have never worked so hard.The new coach is not going to accept anything but success. He is going to play small ball and bunt his way to a CIF Title. Great arms with a major league coach. Demanding head coach who will run his players and not even listen to parent complaints. Who is this masked man????

purple said:

Don,

I like your post's their always entertaining and informative. Diamond Bar is looking all right, I think they will battle in the ever so tough Sierra League. Watched a few innings of their game last Saturday their short stop made some great plays. They hit the ball well! the outfield was shacky to say the least. By the time I got there it was the 5 or 6 pitcher, so I can't comment on that.

Your friend,

Purple Brahma

Don said:


Purple,

No funnin', I love you guys, used to live on that side of the holler and went to many Brahma games back in the day.

I'm only working that ONE GUY who doesn't know the Inland Valley Daily Bulletin has DB as part of their circ area.

You guys ought to be OK this year in a really tough league.

Good Luck,

Don

scotter said:

Fred,

I would have no problem with that if it was the best teams.
By the way, Diamond Bar is NOT part of the SGV!
Fred try's to make you all feel better but the truth is the truth. I cleared the air for you Fred. You owe me dinner for that.

FredJ said:

What I'm hearing about Shirley is that West Covina is citing "undue influence," making his transfer very difficult. I don't know why school's fight it so hard, just let the kids play.

FredJ said:

What you have to realize is these are top ten previews, not entire Valley previews. We just don't have the space or time to do a complete thorough job of all the teams anymore. And sorry, but the best teams are the best teams, and you will continue to read about them the most. That's why it's great when someone comes in here and talks about the others, that's what this blog is for.

Purple said:

Don,


Come on show Diamond Bar some love! Your always making fun of us....Your giving us a complex! Making fun of our purple socks!

Your Friend,

Purple Brahma
(purple people eater)

no clue said:

Maybe someone can explain why WC would fight shirley's release. How many kid's are at SH on permits from WC. Can someone explain?

Don said:

Reading Steve Ramirez' Softball preview I realized that I wasn't satisfied with it (like all the rest of you whiners) and couldn't expect to be happy with the Baseball preview no matter what day it comes out.

So . . . I decided what we need is an alternative Baseball preview, sort of something for those of us who just aren't going to be happy reading about Northview and Klena again and how Rio will skip the High School season to head right for his Cooperstown induction .

A little something for the rest of us:


1.La Verne Lutheran – Rumor is the Trojans have brought in Davey Johnson for 2009
2.Gladstone - Great field, the Head Coach's pants will fit me, and nicknamed Happy Rock
3.West Covina – Passionate fans and really close to that Hollenbeck Park action too
4.St. Lucy's – Hey, if Ramirez won't put them on his Softball list, I'll use 'em here
5.Covina – What, no Pills left? May have to re-visit this one
6.Western Christian – The lady at Ralphs said they were going to be really good this year
7.Diamond Bar – Yeah I know they aren't in the Trib's circulation area, but they don't
8.Rosemead – Fear the meat! Whooot!
9.Damien – They'll probably be on Fredo's list too but they can't get enough action here
10.Wilson – Everyone deserves a little attention without using Hoyd's name, right?

Alice Bowie said:

Damien, No Complaining? I am on the floor laughing.
Ha Ha Ha. It will take the real 2nd coming to shut up Damien parents. HA HA HA

Pitch said:

Who do they have to pitch? It will be tough for Damien without pitching! The Sierra League is stacked with great hitters. Every team in the Sierra can hit, hit, hit! Pitching will be the biggest factor.

Will Jones said:

Looks like Damien will go undeafeted this year. Genious for a coach and pitching coach. New drills and insights on how to coach. These new coaches are the 2nd coming and the parents will hop on board there will be no complaining at all!!!!

Leave a comment

Fred Robledo

Fred Robledo is the Prep Sports Editor for the San Gabriel Valley Tribune. E-mail me your opinions, story ideas or tips to fred.robledo@sgvn.com.

Subscribe to RSS feed

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Fred Robledo published on March 3, 2009 9:24 AM.

McConnell: Pomona tourney was historic was the previous entry in this blog.

Re-leaguing won't be easy, nice or fair is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Photos

Recent Comments

Legal Downloads on Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied: Wow!, this was a real quality post. In theory I'd like to write like t ...

Legal Downloads on Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied: This is my first time I have visited here. I found a lot of interestin ...

sprzedam jacht on Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied: Sweet - happy new year! ...

Jack Michaels on Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied: Judy North...you want athletes to come to your school, but you won't l ...

Message to Jake Shirley... on Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied: Make an appeal to CIF State. Hey if that b-baller at Workman CJ Guerre ...

right on Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied: its not up to WC for him to be ok to play its covina unified that does ...

Get the story right on Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied: I know cause I've been informed by different coaches on what happened ...

2009 on Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied: Get the story right--unless you're an administrator at WC how do you k ...

Get the story right on Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied: McCuff, nice little spin job, your twisting this thing a 180 degree's ...

Huskies on Baseball Preview Thursday; Shirley Denied: right, Good Luck! ...

Powered by Movable Type 4.25

Advertisement

Other blogs

Authorities confirm identity of Pomona plane crash victim in Crime Scene
This has been the year of the coach ... in Best High School Sports Blog - Fred Robledo Talks Prep Sports
WDN Touchdown Table: Your Predictions and ours in Steve Ramirez talks Prep Sports
Star Picks: Which one is Game of the Week to you? in High School Sports Blog -- From The Sidelines with Miguel Melendez
Whale watching continues in Dana Point in Tanks for the Memories