Was the 1992 Bishop Amat football team the best in San Gabriel Valley history?

San Gabriel Valley Tribune sports historian Jim McConnell put together a list of the best football teams in San Gabriel Valley history a couple years ago. With football season winding down with the state championships on Saturday, it’s fun to look back at who McConnell thought was the best of the best. In subsequent articles, he called the 1992 Bishop Amat team the best ever. Look at all the teams on his list, did he get it right? Click on the link and you decide….

amatno1
Jim McConnell’s top 24 football teams in Valley History
1926 Covina (11-1), CIF-SS Large Schools champion. Probably the best of coach Chief Newman’s three CIF championship teams of the 1920s, this one featured the multi-talented Gus Shaver.

1939 Alhambra (11-0), CIF-SS Large Schools champion. Likely the best of a long string of outstanding Moors teams coached by George Hobbs, this squad featured a high-powered single-wing offense led by Johnny Petrovich.

1942 Bonita (11-0), CIF-SS Central Division champion. In addition to all-time great Davis, this Bearcats team also had Duane Whitehead, later a star at USC, and Glenn’s twin brother Ralph, who later played with his brother on the outstanding Army teams of the mid-1940s.

1951 Pomona (12-0), CIF-SS Large Schools champion. Coached by Harold “Hoppy” Hopkins and led by Marty Keough, the greatest athlete in Pomona history.

1955 San Marino (13-0), CIF-SS Northern Division champion. Coached by Vic Schwenk, this was one of the legendary scoring machines in CIF history.

1964 Whittier (13-0), CIF-SS Large Schools champion. Coached by Vic Lopez and featuring linebacker/guard George Buehler, the best of a long line of outstanding Whittier teams.

1965 West Covina (12-1), CIF-SS 3A Division champion. One of the valley’s best-ever defensive units, coached by Mal Eaton.

1966 El Rancho (13-0), CIF-SS Large Schools champion. Ernie Johnson coached a series of strong El Rancho teams in the 1960s, but this one answered all challenges, including whipping favored Anaheim 35-14 in the CIF title game at the Coliseum.

1969 Blair (13-0), CIF-SS Large Schools champion. Pete Yoder’s team featured the talents of running backs Kermit Johnson and James McAllister and also had one of the best defenses in CIF history.

1970 Bishop Amat (12-1), CIF-SS Large Schools champion. With Pat Haden throwin’ ‘em and J.K. McKay catchin’ ‘em, this was state-of-the-art football for its era. The team was coached by Gary Marinovich, although the rumor remains that USC’s John McKay devised the Lancers’ offensive schemes.

1971 Bishop Amat (12-0), CIF-Large Schools champion. So who was the better quarterback, Pat Haden or John Sciarra? This Sciarra-led Amat team beat all comers, something the Haden-led 1969 and 1970 Amat teams failed to do.

1972 St. Paul (13-0), CIF-SS Large Schools champion. Ancich’s best team, although there is plenty of competition. However, this one had the aforementioned Quirk at quarterback. While he went on to a successful pro baseball career, people often forget he had a full football ride to Notre Dame. The Irish instead had to “settle” for Joe Montana.

1982 Los Altos (14-0), CIF-SS Southern Division champion. DeWayne DeSpain coached numerous championship teams at Los Altos, but the choice here is the 1982 Conquerors, with Mike Smith at quarterback.

1984 Claremont (14-0), CIF-SS Eastern Conference champion. One of many outstanding teams coached by Bob Baiz. This one featured the talents of quarterback Dan McGwire and wide receiver Travis Watkins.

1984 Diamond Bar (14-0), CIF-SS Southeastern Conference champion. The best of coach Terry Roche’s teams, this group set a slew of scoring records en route to its unbeaten season.

1985 Charter Oak (13-0), CIF-SS Southeastern Conference champion. The first of what has become a dynasty at the Covina school, this one probably remains coach Lou Farrar’s best. One of the best-balanced teams in CIF history.

1986 Muir (14-0), CIF-SS Coastal Conference champion. It’s a close call as to which of Brownfield’s Muir teams was the best, but the opinion here is it was this 1986 contingent.

1991 Baldwin Park (12-2), CIF-SS Division IV champion. A long shot for sure, but it would be interesting to see how coach Tony Zane’s complex passing attack – ran to perfection by this team – would fare against the big boys. This squad also had an underrated defense, as evidenced by a 28-7 victory over Nogales in the CIF title game.

1992 Bishop Amat (15-0), CIF-SS Division I champion. Led by Rodney Sermons and Daylon McCutcheon, this Amat team wasn’t as spectacular as other Amat champions but was remarkably efficient, especially on defense.

1995 Diamond Bar (14-0), CIF-SS Division III champion. Another Roche-coached team, many felt this squad was even better than his more heralded 1984 group. It capped a perfect season by beating a potent Newbury Park team, 30-21, in the CIF title game.

1996 Wilson (14-0), CIF-SS Division VI champion. Easily the best team in school history, this squad coached by Tom Caines featured a near-unstoppable running game and a stifling defense. The Wildcats beat arch-rival Los Altos 34-13 in the title game. It doesn’t get any better than that.

2000 Los Altos (14-0), CIF-SS Division VII champion. An outstanding coach, Greg Gano, a balanced offense and a sensational defense – featuring a pass rush led by Shaun Cody – made this Conquerors squad a tough foe for anyone.

2000 South Hills (13-1), CIF-SS Division IX champion. Steve Bogan has coached a decade’s worth of championship teams at South Hills and has earned the reputation as one of the best game managers in the business. It would be interesting to see how this team fared in a title game against any of the above foes.

2002 La Habra (13-1), CIF-SS Division IX champion. Like Bogan at South Hills, La Habra’s Frank Mazzotta now has a decade’s worth of outstanding teams to his coaching credit. This Highlanders squad quite possibly was the best of the lot.

Facebook Twitter Plusone Digg Reddit Stumbleupon Tumblr Email
  • Mike Robledo

    I would include in this group the 2011 West Covina Bulldogs… the final score in the championship game justifies its inclusion alone..

    • FredJ

      I don’t know, look at the teams on the list, who do you put West Covina ahead of? All those teams in the 80s and earlier played when there were only a few divisions and it was much harder to win. Since the 90s, hard to put West Covina ahead of any of these teams.

      • Mike Robledo

        I wouldn’t put West Covina ahead of any of them… your point is fair and valid.. how will teams that win CIF Championships this decade be looked back on 20+ years from now? do they have to win a state bowl?

        • FredJ

          They will be looked back as CIF champions but not among the best of the best. You’re right, a state bowl would go a long way.

          • TheCloser

            The 1992 Amat team won the Reebok Bowl, the closest thing to state bowl these days and was an unprecedented 15-0 at the time.

          • Jastrab

            While mythical, the El Rancho team I believe were crowned national champions in ’66. The only valley team to ever do that!

    • Valley Athletics

      Can’t be the best in history if people still question if that team could of beat Amat or Charter oak that year . They did get blown out by Loyola , a team Amat beat .

  • The stands

    Fred, do you have any source info as to which teams Amat will schedule for pre-season next year? There are a few openings. I know SM and Rancho are locked in but beyond that?

  • G-Stone128

    The 1984 D-Bar team and the 1985 CO team were the best SGV teams I have ever seen play. I think the 1984 D-Bar team crushed a good Baldwin Park team in the finals. I believe the 1985 CO team easily beat a very good Diamond Bar team. This goes way back when the Montview League actually had excellent teams.

  • Missing in action

    The author of this article left out some obvious teams. Los Altos had 3 top division championships in 73,76 (4A) and 77 (Big 5) – South Hills won the 4A title in 74 – St. Paul in 81 (Big 5) and Amat in 95 (D1) all of these teams won divisions at that highest level of play in the Southern Section and should be considered better then any of these other teams that are listed with lower level championships. Also, Diamond Bar had two D2 Championships in the late 90′s as did Muir in 89, teams that would easily have beaten most if not all the lower level teams that are listed here.

  • Ranch Man

    Idk if any valley team can top winning a mythical National Championship… By Default has to go to that 1966 El Rancho High School football team.

  • TheCloser

    How many NFL guys did this team have?

  • New York

    The 1994 Amat team was even better. Mater Dei was too tough of a matchup that night. I think McCutcheon hurt his ankle on his first touchdown run, which was pretty awesome, that night.

    • TheCloser

      The 1994 was stacked (4 future NFL guys on the roster and an endless amount of D1 guys) but Bruce Rollingson outcoached then rookie head coach Tom Salter. If Paredes doesn’t leave that summer they have a National Championship banner hanging in the gym.

      • New York

        That Mater Dei offensive line was awfully physical, as was MD’s fullback. They ran right at Kory Minor like two battering rams colliding. Still, Amat was loaded and should have won that game.

  • DHighAlum

    Only a Bishop alumni would post this blog. Anything bishop he rides on.