Notre Dame report
Here is the report card for the Notre Dame game:
Notre Dame 20, UCLA 6
Record: 4-2; Week 6 grade: F
Quarterbacks
Walk-on McLeod Bethel-Thompson was put in a very difficult position and poor play calling didn’t help, but in there is no overlooking four INTs, three fumbles (one lost) and a number of very poorly thrown balls. He was 12 of 28 for 139 yards, after Ben Olson went 4 of 10 for 54 yards, and also lost a fumble.
Grade: F
Running backs
Kahlil Bell lost a fumble on the first play after Notre Dame tied it 6-6, and also dropped a pass in the left corner of the end zone that could have pulled UCLA within seven points late in the fourth quarter. Christian Ramirez, who hurt his knee when he was hit in a non-contact drill in Thursday’s practice, didn’t play.
Grade: F
Receivers
Brandon Breazell and Joe Cowan had the same statistics (5 catches, 69 yards), but Breazell also had a ball go through his hands, which allowed Notre Dame to grab another interception. Frankly, it doesn’t matter how this unit did. Six points against this team doesn’t deserve anything but a failure. Holding penalty on TE Logan Paulsen negated a long Cowan touchdown catch.
Grade: F
Offensive line
Five sacks from the Irish, a bunch more hurries, a 2.4 yard rushing average and the inability to move the ball with regularity were the low points of first-year coach Bob Connelly’s crew. Good teams can run the ball even when the opponent knows it is coming. UCLA could not, despite what is supposed to be a talented offensive line.
Grade: F
Defensive line
Bruce Davis backed up his words during the week with three sacks, and the Irish netted 46 yards on 38 carries, but who figured UCLA’s offensive line would block less than Notre Dame’s. The Irish’s three offensive scores came on drives of minus-7 yards, 2 yards and 29 yards. Now, if this group can figure out to score points, UCLA may win again.
Grade: A
Linebackers
Just look at the 140 total yards of offense Notre Dame had and it’s easy to see how much UCLA’s defense dominated. Christian Taylor had six tackles, including two for loss, and Kyle Bosworth made four stops. Maybe this unit can brainstorm with the DL to figure out how to score more points.
Grade: A
Secondary
Notre Dame didn’t send many guys out in patterns, and the longest pass QB Jimmy Clausen completed with 15 yards. He averaged less than five yards on his 17 completions, so there wasn’t much chance for INTs. Alterraun Verner thought he had one, but he was called for pass interference.
Grade: A
Special teams
Kai Forbath made both his field goal attempts, Aaron Perez saw three of his five punts downed inside the 20 and the coverage teams were good. However, the Bruins needed to make something happen in the return game to aid the awful offense, and that didn’t take place.
Grade: B
Coaching
Defensive coordinator DeWayne Walker did a great job, but that was offset by a terrible situation at quarterback, and mind-numbing play calls that had players shaking their heads. Fourth-and-1 with a third-string walk-on red-shirt frosh QB, and it’s a rollout? With ND not moving the ball, third-and-6 from your own 5 and another rollout, which is intercepted? How about putting the offense in position to be successful? Take a lesson from Charlie Weis on how not to let your inexperienced QB cost you a game. If only there were a lower grade to give.
Grade: F
Comments
Brian, While I like Coach Dorrel as a person. How do we get rid of this guy and bring in a quality coach?
Posted by: James Pettit | October 8, 2007 08:47 AM
Hey James ... the answer to your question is on our website today. Click on my ID below this post to find out.
Posted by: DumpDorrell | October 8, 2007 09:23 AM
Brian, that is the first I've heard of "...players shaking their heads" at play calls Saturday night although it is unfortunately not surprising. Why we didn't just run the ball with minimal passing with a 3rd string QB in order to play for the ugly 9-6 or 12-6 win is beyond me as it was readily apparent ND's offense wasn't going to do a thing against the Bruin D Saturday night.
Also, you were spot on at the beginning of the season when you thought we might have problems up front on the O-line.
Posted by: sdbruinfan | October 8, 2007 09:27 AM
Brian,
Grade F is way too generous. In most academic institutions, you are allowed to take a class over when receiving a failing grade. In this case, it's impossible.
How about expulsion from school?
Posted by: Trey
|
October 8, 2007 11:08 AM
Brian,
one area where Notre Dame did great was when they punted.
Austin is not Maurice Drew, and I think the blocking for MD was much better in '05. But the hang time pretty much allowed ND to get close to TA and not allow any significant return yards.
Posted by: Anonymous | October 8, 2007 12:25 PM
My immediate reaction when Bethel-Thompson dropped back to pass on that 4th-and-1 play, after he's already thrown some bad balls (like missing the RB on a easy behind-the-scrimmage pass), was "aww, c'mon. Are you %^$# stupid!?"
Posted by: Li Tai Fang | October 8, 2007 12:53 PM
Quick question about Saturday's attendance of 78,000 and change. Is that figure right? I could have swore the Rose Bowl was packed with very few empty seats. I know the stadium holds about 92,000 or thereabouts. I was expecting the crowd count to be in the upper 80,000 mark. But 78,000? Did somebody miscount somewhere? I'm really curious. How is attendance calculated anyway? Paid tickets sold or the number of folks showing up at the game?
Posted by: Chey | October 8, 2007 02:35 PM
Brian,
As I was telling my wife, not even if UCLA had Joe Montana in his NFL prime would that 4th and 1 have been a good call. I know that Jay Norvell likely made that call, but I am quite certain that Dorrell could have overturned it had the thought crossed his mind that the call was highly imprudent. I believe that UCLA was up 6-3 at the time, and instead of UCLA going up 13-3 or 9-3, we allowed ND to subsequently march down the field for the tying field goal (CKD needs to take tips from Weis). The tide turned after this forcing us to further call imprudent plays that led to more turnovers. Dan needs to fire Dorrell after the '08 kids sign in February. Can't handle ANY more of his ineptitude.
Posted by: Robert | October 8, 2007 02:38 PM
The WCO experiment has failed.
And Dorrell has wasted way too many reps on Ben Olson.
Posted by: BluBlood | October 8, 2007 06:15 PM
How about an F- for offensive coaching. You hit on it above, even 12 year olds who follow football, like my nephew sitting next to me, knew that we needed to keep MBT out of situations where the game rested on his shoulders. Roll out on a 4th and 1 - when you're in FG range with our defense? That may have been the worst call in college football this season!
Posted by: Bruin 1 | October 9, 2007 10:47 AM