Here’s a Utah fan’s case to vote the Utes No. 1.

Utah is the only unbeaten team in America.
Utah has four wins over current top 25 teams (Alabama, TCU, BYU, Oregon State)
Utah has two wins over top 10 teams (Alabama, TCU)
Utah won a conference that is arguably the 3rd or 4th strongest in college football this year, and went 6-1 against the Pac- 10 in the regular season.
Oklahoma’s best win came against TCU, Florida’s best win came against Alabama, and the only team to beat USC was Oregon St. Utah beat all three of these teams this season.
Utah soundly beat an Alabama team that was one quarter away from a national championship game birth.