« How Do You Do! | Main | One More Answer »

Open Forum Answers

I don't know what's worse, answering all these questions or listening to Petros Papadakis say, ``Mitch Moose-stain.''

There was talk last summer between Pete Carroll and Karl Dorrell about both teams wearing their home uniforms. Carroll said last season he would not mind if UCLA wore their home jerseys this year.
However, there is an increasing frostiness between the coaching staffs right now, so I wouldn’t expect any friendly gestures to occur this summer.

Pete Carroll’s pushed for rules banning agents from talking to recruits and has also talked to the NCAA and NFL about this. Some view this as hypocritical, because Carroll’s often been closely involved in helping guide players to certain agents.
However, due to the lowly image of agents, there’s been little public criticism of the idea, although it doesn’t seem close to happening.
USC did sue agent Robert Caron when it was alleged that running back Shawn Walters accepted nearly $16,000 from Caron. Caron later paid the university $50,000 to settle the lawsuit brought against him by USC because of the incident.

Joe McKnight’s groin is strained but he should be OK.

Funniest ex or current players? I always have a tough time answering these questions. There’s funny players and then there are players who think they are funny, like Petros Papadakis.
Two of the funniest players I’ve dealt with are the late Travis Claridge and Winston Justice. Many thought Claridge was gruff, but that was only if he didn’t know you. He was brutally honest and if you asked him about coaches, you’d often get priceless comments.
Justice was a more playful personality. Of course sometimes he was unintentionally funny, like when he mistakenly pointed a pellet gun at a student he thought was a baseball player he knew, but turned out to be a stranger.

There are many rules regarding recruiting regarding how often you can contact a recruit, etc. Usually a school is allowed one contact a recruit once per week unless it is a dead period. Recruits are allowed five official visits, but can also visit schools on their own.
Many times, kids go to a school in the summer on their own and visit, commit, then make an official visit in December or January just to have fun.

I’ve mentioned this many times in the past but was asked again, so here goes: Norm Chow left because of a deteriorating relationship with Pete Carroll and he felt he was getting pushed out because he was going to have a different job title than offensive coordinator.
Chow and current offensive coordinator Steve Sarkisian had a falling out over the incident and pretty much stopped talking. Sarkisian is obviously influenced by Chow but he’s also influenced by Carroll and Norv Turner.
I believe USC can win a national title without Chow, but I know they haven’t won one without him yet, and blew perhaps the easiest chance ever in 2005 due to controversial playcalling/personnel use.

I haven’t heard yet if Ronald Johnson will arrive early from Michigan.

Carroll said Josh Pinkard will play safety next season. Once the season starts, however, things can play. The only thing I’m confident about is that Pinkard will see the field somehow.

Closure on the Reggie Bush saga before the season seems a little idealistic right now. The truth is no one knows when it will end. Things are progressing slowly, but the NCAA is not giving up yet, so anything is possible.

It’s pronounced Ch-eye-low Rayshell (Chilo Rachal)

I don’t see Marc Tyler getting switched yet, at least until the coaches get a good look at him at tailback. But about a year ago, USC seemed more interested in signing him as a defensive player. Who would he beat out at safety? Taylor Mays? Kevin Ellison? Josh Pinkard?
Allen Bradford and C.J. Gable are the usual suspects to switch positions although I’m beginning to think Bradford might be better off switching to linebacker if he moves again. He would probably veto it because he thinks his NFL future lies at safety or running back.
Stafon Johnson could easily move to defense and Washington recruited him to play offense and defense, but no one at USC’s asked him to yet.

USC did not think Jimmy Clausen was damaged goods and recruited him aggressively. However, like many big-time players, when you lose out on them, you recognize some of the future problems/baggage you avoid by not having that player in the program.

I think whoever loses out the QB battle in spring, 2008, will consider transferring. Sanchez would have some issues as a redshirt sophomore, because if he transfers, he would have only one year of eligibility. It’s impossible to say today what will happen. Matt Leinart thought about transferring constantly in 2002 but never did.

Jeff Byers is currently healthy. The offensive line looks pretty solid right now with maybe one question being how Drew Radovich makes the transition from guard to tackle. And will any of the reserves turn into a reliable contributor?

There are a handful of recruits who could have NCAA Clearinghouse issues. Since many are just finishing high school right now, it’s too soon to say for sure who they are.
Allen Bradford remains the logical candidate to switch from tailback to fullback, but it’s also possible Thomas Williams would return there. Josh Pinkard and Mozique McCurtis are the two players who can play safety and cornerback and Pinkard can play both at an elite level.

Once again, people need to take Trojan Club comments for what they are. The quarterback position is not open this training camp (barring a total collapse by John David Booty). I would not say Pete Carroll is higher on Mustain than Sanchez. For one thing, he’s never really seen Mustain practice regularly, so he doesn’t even have a fully formed opinion yet.

Regarding Nick Young and Gabe Pruitt, Young left with Floyd’s blessing and he looks destined to be a lottery pick, so no argument there.
Pruitt, however, left under far more strained circumstances and his refusal to remain in good academic standing means USC could lose a scholarship under the APR guidelines. I’m hearing he could go in the top 20 now, so he isn’t exactly making a mistake, but he didn’t leave the program on the best terms.
I saw O.J. Mayo play the other night and he will be a major impact player. He will leave after his freshman season unless he suffers a major injury. However, a college basketball coach told me this week that UCLA recruit Kevin Love will have an even bigger impact, especially because he joins a stronger team.
As for the other freshman, Marcus Simmons will be a defensive specialist and center Mamadou Diarra will add much-needed size even though he is still learning and not polished.
This week I wrote that forward Davon Jefferson was raw. Only a rah-rah type would consider that a controversial comment since USC coach Tim Floyd speaks in similar terms about him. Jefferson’s got a long way to go before leaving for the NBA, frankly I don’t even consider that an issue and he looked like someone who had not played organized basketball for a couple of years. He will definitely help the team but there’s clearly going to be a transition period.

Stanley Havili will start at fullback. But will he stay healthy and who will back him up? Those are the real questions regarding the position.

I would never use a pre-season magazine to determine how tough a schedule is. Any time you go to Eugene, Ore., it’s a game you need to take seriously. And I’ve covered the past two USC blowouts up there, although the 2005 game was actually pretty close for a half.
Going to Seattle could also be tough if Washington is as improved as they appear to be. And maybe Notre Dame will stink this year, but then again, maybe they’ll play like their season depends on beating USC in South Bend. I consider USC’s road schedule to be very difficult. Think back two years ago. With Matt Leinart, Reggie Bush, LenDale White, etc., USC nearly lost at Arizona State, played a very physical game at Cal and got a handful at Oregon for a half. They play those same teams this year on the road.

An official visit is when the school pays for the recruit to visit. If the recruit pays, it’s an unofficial visit. Recruits get five visits.

To earn a letter, you must be an active member of the team for the season. That means you practice, go to meetings, etc.

UCLA has a lot of commitments because they are aggressively recruiting after being limited in whom they could take last season when they didn’t have many scholarships. I think USC would quickly take Datone Jones, Aaron Hester and E.J. Woods if they changed their minds. Rahim Moore might also fall into that group to lesser extent.
USC also was high on Derrick Coleman, who committed to UCLA last weekend.
Otherwise, that might be it.
At the end of the day, how much does it matter? USC will sign a lot of players in February and like I said previously, the Trojans will probably recruit more nationally the rest of this year as they try to land players like linebackers Arthur Brown and Brendan Beal and safety/cornerback Deion Walker. There’s more than enough recruits to go around.
I haven’t seen the ratings for Maurice Simmons, but his little brother (also committed) is regarded as the best prospect. UCLA would have taken both of them.
To answer another question on this topic, I believe USC feels it waited too long to offer Hester, Jones and Woods. Why? Because before this offseason, you could wait longer to lock up recruits and Pete Carroll usually takes things slowly. But everything is moving faster now. Ask Dennis Erickson if he enjoys this new atmosphere.
USC can still be more selective because it is a nationally known program but they definitely are being more aggressive in response to the flurry of commitments.

Do I read all the comments to my postings? No. Sometimes I never read comments on postings, and sometimes, I wish I hadn’t read the comments. I could spend a day reading Mitch Mustain comments. But I do read all the open forum comments.

All I know about the Pac-10 is they made a huge mistake when they did not make the Cotton Bowl their No. 2 bowl. If you look at the other major conferences, none of them send their second team to a lousy bowl like the Holiday Bowl. There’s no glamour or anything if a USC or UCLA goes to San Diego. But a trip to the Cotton Bowl . . . USC still talks about its 1995 visit and I have fond memories of going to Dallas myself.
The lousy officiating is also an issue, but think of some of the blunders in the Big Ten or Big 12 over the years. However, I think Verle Sorgen will be a big loss as supervisor of officials especially when his replacement was suspended for a game following last year’s Oregon-Oklahoma debacle.
At Heritage Hall, there is occasional disenchantment but USC is not going to leave the Pac-10. That ship sailed 20 years ago.

One of my critiques of the Galen Center is that it has a kind of Spartan/pre-fabricated look on the outside. I once told Tim Floyd it reminded me of Costco, which should offend someone out there. However, the parking structures were built by the university so the athletic dept. had little say over their design.

Bradford and Averill Spicer will be reserves who could be good second-tier players. Galippo is a wild card. It’s hard to learn middle linebacker and play right away but he is intelligent. But he also plays behind Rey Maualuga. So he might get a year to learn the spot. I think Galippo will find a way to get on the field, whether at linebacker, special teams or maybe a surprise spot.

I’m not impressed with the talent in Southern California this year. It seems like a down year. Last weekend’s football camp at USC was dreadful. Nationally, that might not be the case. USC can give out 25 scholarships in February, which is the maximum amount. However, you can give out more if you bring in players in January because they don’t count as part of that 25.
USC’s available scholarships changes because players can transfer, become ineligible or quit. For instance, USC gave BYU basketball player Jordan Cameron a scholarship this week even though some might assume there were no more full rides available.

A hamstring usually takes about six weeks to recover.

So far, I don’t think the early commits are as strong as a year ago, but it’s really a question to answer in February. One reason might be that it’s not as strong a year for prospects. This year’s incoming group is good but they haven’t played yet so let’s wait and see first.

Haven’t heard of anyone going to San Jose State like Jeff Schweiger.

Is that it? Doesn’t anyone else have another Mitch Mustain/Mark Sanchez question?

Or want to know which players have long hair or short hair?

How do you do!

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.insidesocal.com/MT/mt-tb.cgi/13100

Comments

hahaha, i didn't ask any questions this week Scott because you've answered them all.

Great work though.

hahaha, i didn't ask any questions this week Scott because you've answered them all.

Great work though.

Great work again Scott. I look forward to your answers next week.
Also, good work on Rivals radio. It looks like the experts asked you similar questions as the ones posted on this blog :)

Fight On!

keep up the good work scott.

"I think Galippo will find a way to get on the field, whether at linebacker, special teams or maybe a surprise spot." ....Scott, could the "surprise spot" possibly be fullback? He was a bruising runner in high school.

Wow, you're the first person to say that Verle the Trojie will be missed. I have yet to meet a non-Trojan who felt that VTT was worth his salt as the Director of Officiating and the fact he is a decorated SC athlete undermined his credibility at least as much as what others saw as his failure to admit that SC benefited from more than its fair share of calls (e.g., R. Bush fumble at the Rose Bowl in 2004).

I am glad you wrote this below. USC website doesn't want reality. I have written this several times and got the type of responses you do not want to read:
"I’ve mentioned this many times in the past but was asked again, so here goes: Norm Chow left because of a deteriorating relationship with Pete Carroll and he felt he was getting pushed out because he was going to have a different job title than offensive coordinator.
Chow and current offensive coordinator Steve Sarkisian had a falling out over the incident and pretty much stopped talking. Sarkisian is obviously influenced by Chow but he’s also influenced by Carroll and Norv Turner.
I believe USC can win a national title without Chow, but I know they haven’t won one without him yet, and blew perhaps the easiest chance ever in 2005 due to controversial playcalling/personnel use."

I believe with Chow USC beats both UCLA in 06 Texas by 21. PC had a shot at Woodenesque 4 in row and going on 5 but lost it to his ego,i.e. Chow getting too much credit. He was mentioned on OB game vs Sooners telecast more than Carroll.
PC is greata DC and as a pair they had it all.

I also believe Mustain should have gone to Hawaii. Just not right that one gets pine or transfers.

Thanks for answering everyone's questions. I actually didn't ask any this week!

I also have fond memories of the 1995 Cotton Bowl. Keyshawn ...wow.

Thank you Wolfe. Great job as usual. We appreciate your hardwork. I can not think of any other newspaper writers that keep us this well informed during the offseason.

Thanks Scott... I gotta agree with you... seems like this year's top recuits aren't as well publicized as last year. Or maybe, this year's top players aren't as good as last year. But again, it's still early in the recruiting year.

Thanx again, Scott--complete and honest and insightful answers to everything. I bet you don't really know how many of us have come to really look forward to the open forum. Thank you again. Also, if I may, my sincere thanx to readers gillyking and usc1966 for their helpful suggestions re versus. I am happy to report that, for those of us served by charter comm., they are carrying versus on channel 410, so we can watch the stanford game! By the way, I too think we would have 4 straight nat'l championships if Norm would have stayed. it's too bad that they couldn't have worked things out. I also heard that Norm and Kiffin were having personal problems too. At any rate, Pete and Norm were a great combination and it was fun while it lasted. I am really glad Kiff is gone-now lets see what Sark has. Any injuries on the ol could kill us this year tho--the reserves are an unknown bunch as Scott has said. Also, fb remains a problem as it's Havili and nothing. Pete should get a show of hands{a la Sonny Byrd], find out who wants to play, then who can block and catch-that should be a priority for Fall practice. Then immerse a couple in the mental aspects--and I mean really immerse!

Does everyone really believe that if we had Chow, we would have won four straight National Championships? Aside from the inherently speculative nature of the question, I don't know that it holds up to scrutiny.

USC lost to Texas not because of offense, but because the defense could not stop two late fourth quarter TD drives engineered by Vince Young. (Apparently, some NFL defenses had the same problem of not stopping Young toward the end of last year as well.) The offense gave us a big lead, and the defense couldn't hold it. (Granted that is Carroll's Department, and led to him hiring Holt as DC.) Chow had nothing to do with the defense. Scoring 38 points should have been sufficient. We might have scored more if Reggie hadn't made the biggest bonehead play in Rose Bowl history (excluding wrong-way Roy Riegels in 1929) by errantly pitching the football away deep in Longhorn territory.

As for the loss to Oregon State, it was again the defense that let the Beavers get a big lead in the 3rd quarter before the offense did a tremendous job of coming all the way back until the 2-pt pass was tipped.

As for the UCLA loss, I hate to admit it, but the offensive line was vulnerable to the quick UCLA defensive line. Only Eric Scott's athletic tip and dive to intercept prevented USC from coming through in the end. This was the first time in 64 games that USC was held below 20 pts, the last 22 or so of which were without Chow.

Thus, there was only one game - UCLA in 2006 - where the offense did not live up to its expectations. Further, I don't think we would have needed Chow to destroy the Buckeyes, assuming hypothetically that we beat UCLA and/or Oregon St.

I wish Chow had stayed too, and he is a great offensive mind, but we can't just automatically assume that USC wins the national championship the last two years with him.

I ditto all that TIREBITER1 said.

Sonny Byrd...the surfer tough guy. He had big role in program change. His fighting for yards and taking short passes made defenses have to protect him and gave Palmer needed balance and time to throw. Teamed turned around when he emerged. Sad he got so little playing time in 2002 but wasn't it great to seem in that drive in OB.

I love Sonny Byrd and tonight I want all of you to love him, too.

Scott,

You are wrong about the reasons for the challenging relationship of Carroll and Chow.

Coach Carroll had to make plans, decisions and moves in order to protect HIS program. After Chow's third year at USC he began throwing his name in the hat for every quality head coaching opening. First Nebraska then Stanford in 2004, and 2005. Each recruting year this caused havoc with recruits as a result of the significant instability of the offensive coordinator and program. Norm Chow derserves a chance to be a head coach however, Coach Carroll needed to make plans for Chow's eventual departure. Chow slowly lost influence on the program because each year Coach Carroll expected to lose his wonder Offensive Coordinator. Coach Carroll had no choice but to prepare for this event...this is what is expected from a Head Coach.

If Norm Chow does not understand this simple fact, then perhaps he is not ready for a Head Coaching job. He should learn with regards to running a full program "if you fail to plan then you plan to fail"

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Scott Wolf

Scott Wolf has covered USC for the Daily News since 1996. A USC graduate, he covered his first Trojan game in 1984 for the Daily Trojan. Scott is known as the "scourge of the Internet message boards," according to radio host Petros Papadakis. Despite this moniker, there's no truth to the rumor he takes pleasure in antagonizing the "Internet geeks."

Categories

Powered by
Movable Type 3.2