And Another Question

| | Comments (8) |

If the NCAA committed factual errors in its investigation, as alleged, regarding Todd McNair, why was he fired?


8 Comments

Sy Author Profile Page said:

Actually, McNair was not fired. His contract expired after which McNair and USC did not come to a new agreement. No comment has been made, but it is assumed that USC felt McNair was too limited in his ability to assist USC as he cannot talk to recruits, which is a major function of his job. Also, he is radioactive with regards to just being there as he may answer a phone when a recruit called, run into a recruit on the field while working with the team, etc., etc., etc. Just a claim could be enough for additional sanctions.

Essentially, the NCAA forced USC to let his contract expire as they made it impossible for him to do his job. It will be some time before we know if any other issues played a part in his departure. He has not been allowed on the field again since the sanctions were released even though USC defends his position.

devildoc Author Profile Page said:

Scott, he wasn't fired, his contract expired and it was not renegotiated.

trjons Author Profile Page said:

because the running backs underachieved and because he wasn't allowed to recruit for a year?

unclejune Author Profile Page said:

He was not retained wolf which is different than being fired. Lets get the real point which is why asleep at the wheel wolf took so long to report that mcnair was not coming back? Gary klein kicks ur ass

unclejune Author Profile Page said:

He was not retained wolf which is different than being fired. Lets get the real point which is why asleep at the wheel wolf took so long to report that mcnair was not coming back? Gary klein kicks ur ass

oh so obvious what happened. Southern Cal gave him a severanve package and McNair signed a confidentiality agreement.

if not, baby he will be singing like a canary.

we'll know for sure when he starts saying, "i can't talk about that"

Wolfie....How about the factual errors in YOUR "investigation"???.... Journalistic McCarthyism at its finest.....

djk1998 Author Profile Page said:

While I don't doubt what Count is saying is possible, I think this is more likely.

1) Firing Coach McNair earlier would have left USC open to a wrongful termination suit. The NCAA's evidence against McNair might hold up in the kangaroo court they run (the NCAA) but in a real court USC would have been pretty vulnerable. The irony here is hilarious. The evidence is good enough for the NCAA to hang USC but not good enough for USC to fire McNair.

2) Firing McNair earlier would have admitted some guilt sooner and weakened the case before the COI hearing. Now that it's over, they have no reason to keep him. By the time the appeal is over, his show cause period will be done for the most part. During that entire time, he'd be pretty useless as a coach.

3) Coach McNair is now free to sue the NCAA in court. The assistant coach involved in the Alabama case did and won. Funny how rules of evidence and due process work against the NCAA.

Fun to watch.

Leave a comment

About Inside USC

Daily News USC beat writer Scott Wolf covers the Trojans in print, at Dailynews.com and with frequent updates on this blog.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Scott Wolf published on July 1, 2010 1:48 PM.

McNair Out was the previous entry in this blog.

McNair Question is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Recent Comments

djk1998 on And Another Question: While I don't doubt what Count is saying is possible, I think this is ...

Trojan Hoarse on And Another Question: Wolfie....How about the factual errors in YOUR "investigation"???.... ...

"Count" Smackula on And Another Question: oh so obvious what happened. Southern Cal gave him a severanve package ...

unclejune on And Another Question: He was not retained wolf which is different than being fired. Lets get ...

unclejune on And Another Question: He was not retained wolf which is different than being fired. Lets get ...

trjons on And Another Question: because the running backs underachieved and because he wasn't allowed ...

devildoc on And Another Question: Scott, he wasn't fired, his contract expired and it was not renegotiat ...

Sy on And Another Question: Actually, McNair was not fired. His contract expired after which McNa ...

Powered by Movable Type 4.25

Search this blog

Loading

Advertisement